subscriber help

such a nasty woman | by maryann johanson

from Facebook: a few thoughts on Harry Potter and the Cursed Child


Update: I was right about fans getting angry over the fact that Cursed Child is a script, not a novel…

posted in:
books | stage buzz
  • Bluejay

    I wonder how many kids will go on to discover a love of theater after reading this?

    Oh, they love it already. Lin-Manuel Miranda got to ’em. :-)


  • Danielm80
  • Bluejay

    Brilliant. :-)

  • Nathan

    This just in, authors are bad people if they revisit their own intellectual property… and if you feed into this behavior you’re basically killing cultural progress.

  • RogerBW

    Meh, it’s just like serial television: if people bought the last one, bring out another one. If they didn’t, don’t. This is why the last one of anything open-ended is almost always rubbish.

  • Danielm80

    Well, yes, but there’s almost universal agreement–even from the author of the essay–that this play isn’t rubbish. But even if it were, that doesn’t mean that audiences like rubbish, or that we aren’t willing to try something new.

    The lesson–if there is one–goes something like this:

    (1.) Large corporations need safe bets, projects that are pretty much guaranteed to make money. That way, they can stay in business and, once in a while, even take a risk on something original.

    (2.) (a.) Audiences may not be nearly as enthusiastic about a rehash of something they used to like. But some projects–like this one–are worth the attention.

    (b.) Some people are foolish enough to fall enough for the hype time after time.

    (c.) And if the large corporations aren’t releasing anything else, audiences may be desperate enough to pay for the rehash.

    (d.) Unless it’s Independence Day: Resurgence.

  • But the potential audience of kiddies discovering theater is *much* larger for the HP play-in-book-form.

  • Bluejay

    As long as they’re not disappointed that it’s not actually a novel. :-)

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This