obsession boyfriend i'm psyched girl crush i'm dreading enemy

(need an explanation?)

advertisements





when in Stratford-upon-Avon, U.K., I stay at
Adelphi Guest House




reviews Fri Sep 17 99, 1:33AM

Earth (review)

Innocence Betrayed
With India and Pakistan seemingly on the verge of throwing nukes at each other, it's enlightening -- but hardly surprising -- to go back to the immediate roots of the contemporary conflict and discover, as we do in Earth, that it's just as senseless as most of the others we find flaring up around the world. As in the former Yugoslavia, as in the Middle East, as in Northern Ireland, the India/Pakistan discord comes down to religion: India is Hindu, Pakistan is Muslim. This divide was created by the British when they withdrew from India in 1947 and split a unified and religiously diverse country into two nations. Millions of people were uprooted -- Hindus were forced to leave the newly created Pakistan, and Muslims in what remained of India were forced to relocate to Pakistan. One million people were killed in religious fighting.

(more below the ad... scroll down...)

I don't think it's an exaggeration to call this the Indian Holocaust, and I don't think it's unfair to liken Earth to Schindler's List, though on a much smaller scale. Deepa Mehta, the Indian-Canadian writer/director of Earth, has created a deeply moving, immensely powerful film that looks at the events of 1947 from a child's point of view, offering us a tiny but clear perspective on how tribal hatreds separate people once close, and how a child's innocence can be used and betrayed.

Nine-year-old Lenny (Maaia Sethna) lives with her wealthy, religiously neutral Parsee parents in Lahore. Lenny spends much of her time with her beautiful nanny, Shanta (Nandita Das), and Shanta's many suitors, including Dil Navaz (Aamir Khan) and Hasan (Rahul Khanna). Shanta is Hindu, Dil Navaz and Hasan are Muslim, and their circle of friends includes Sikhs as well, but they all get along just fine, with only the minor debates you'd expect to find among good friends.

The first half of Earth is relentlessly sunny: a colorful kite festival celebrates spring; her mother teaches Lenny to dance a waltz in their English-style parlor saturated with golden afternoon sunlight; Lenny's family's warm and bright garden is the setting for much of Dil Navaz's and Hasan's wooing of Shanta. We are seeing Lenny's point of view -- as a protected and well-loved child, she is unaware of the discord hovering under the surface of her world, of the seeds of disaster being planted. But we see. We see the hatred starting to simmer beneath the debates among Shanta and her friends -- the group is a microcosm of diverse India. We see the park where Shanta and her friends lounge, once a gathering place for Hindu, Muslim, and Sikh alike, now ominously empty. The question of whether Lahore should go to Pakistan or India is foremost on the minds of all, and the discussion is rancorous. "Why fight among friends?" Hasan asks, but gets only half-hearted agreement.

Earth turns darker with the division of India. The second half of the film is set mostly at night, and its here that the film sears with its images: A pro-Pakistan street protest walks terrifyingly right over Lenny's family's car, smashing its windshield. A silent swarm of Muslim refugees pours through the narrow streets of Lahore, now part of Pakistan, people forced from the new India, wordlessly somber people carrying children, goats, all their possessions on their backs. With the city now officially Muslim, and atrocities by Hindus fresh in the minds of Lahore's Muslims, Shanta is in danger. The previously friendly rivalry between Dil Navaz and Hasan for Shanta's affections turns deadly in this atmosphere, and Lenny, who loves all three of them, will be used in a way that will grow to haunt the adult Lenny who narrates the film.

Part of Deepa Mehta's trilogy on the elements -- Fire, a love story set in contemporary New Delhi, was released in 1996; Water is in preproduction -- Earth nevertheless stands alone as a potently affecting and effective film, one the viewer is not likely to soon forget.

viewed at a private screening with an audience of critics
not rated
official site | IMDB
(more below the ad... scroll down...)



who I am


I'm MaryAnn Johanson: writer and ponderer in New York City who drinks too much wine and thinks way too much about such inconsequences as movies, TV, books, and the meaning of life.
[email me]
[become a Facebook fan]
[visit my personal Facebook page]
[follow me on Twitter]
[friend me on MySpace]

FlickFilosopher.com is available on Kindle

• contributor, Film.com
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences
• visit my scratchpad blog, MaryAnnJohanson.com
• read my Doctor Who fan fiction

photo by David Speranza

(postings feed)


top critic on Movie Review Query Engine


as seen on Rotten Tomatoes


member, Online Film Critics Society


member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists

Add to Technorati Favorites

monthly archives

recent screenings and hot movies

just opened (U.S.)
red for no The Twilight Saga: New Moon
yellow for maybe Planet 51
not viewed by me The Blind Side [trailer]
not viewed by me Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans [trailer]
yellow for maybe Broken Embraces
green for go Red Cliff [trailer]
yellow for maybe The Missing Person [trailer]
green for go Precious (expanding)
green for go Fantastic Mr. Fox (expanding)
just opened (U.K.)
red for no The Twilight Saga: New Moon
green for go A Serious Man
green for go The Informant!
box office top 5 (U.S.)
yellow for maybe 2012
red for no A Christmas Carol
green for go Precious
green for go The Men Who Stare at Goats
yellow for maybe Michael Jackson's This Is It
top limited releases (U.S.)
green for go Precious
red for no The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day
green for go An Education
green for go A Serious Man
yellow for maybe Coco Before Chanel
box office top 5 (U.K.)
yellow for maybe 2012
red for no A Christmas Carol
not viewed by me Harry Brown
green for go Up
green for go The Men Who Stare at Goats
coming soon (U.S./U.K.)
red for no The Loss of a Teardrop Diamond
yellow for maybe Serious Moonlight [trailer]
yellow for maybe A Single Man [trailer]
green for go Everybody's Fine [trailer]
red for no The Strip
green for go The Private Lives of Pippa Lee [trailer]
green for go The Young Victoria [trailer]
green for go Creation [trailer]
green for go The Road [trailer]
green for go The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus [trailer]
other current flicks (U.S./U.K.)
green for go Amelia
red for no Antichrist [trailer]
red for no Astro Boy
yellow for maybe The Box
green for go The Boys Are Back
green for go Bright Star
green for go Capitalism: A Love Story [trailer]
yellow for maybe Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant
yellow for maybe Collapse
red for no Couples Retreat
green for go Creation [trailer]
green for go The Damned United
green for go An Education
green for go Five Minutes of Heaven
yellow for maybe The Fourth Kind
red for no Gentlemen Broncos [trailer]
green for go The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus [trailer]
green for go The Invention of Lying
red for no Jennifer's Body
green for go The Messenger [trailer]
green for go Ong Bak 2: The Beginning
yellow for maybe Paranormal Activity
red for no Pirate Radio (aka The Boat That Rocked)
yellow for maybe A Single Man [trailer]
yellow for maybe Where the Wild Things Are
red for no Whiteout
red for no Women in Trouble
green for go Zombieland

2009 screening log

new on dvd

11.17 (Region 1)
green for go Star Trek [buy]
green for go Humpday [buy]
green for go Bruno [buy]
green for go Is Anybody There? [buy]
yellow for maybe The Limits of Control [buy]
yellow for maybe My Sister's Keeper [buy]
yellow for maybe How to Be [buy]
green for go Farscape: The Complete Series [buy]
green for go Gone with the Wind: 70th Anniversary Ultimate Collector's Edition [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.S.)

11.16 (Region 2)
green for go Star Trek [buy]
green for go Moon [buy]
green for go Sunshine Cleaning [buy]
yellow for maybe Four Christmases [buy]
yellow for maybe Tyson [buy]
green for go An Evening with John Barrowman [buy]
green for go Doctor Who: The Key to Time [buy]
green for go South Park: Christmas Time in South Park [buy]
green for go Star Trek Trilogy [buy]
green for go Star Trek: The Next Generation Movie Collection [buy]
green for go Star Trek: Films 1-10 Remastered Special Edition [buy]
yellow for maybe Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season 2 [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.K.)

11.10 (Region 1)
green for go Up [buy]
red for no The Ugly Truth [buy]
green for go The Sarah Jane Adventures: The Complete Second Season [buy]
green for go Ink [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.S.)

11.09 (Region 2)
green for go Bruno [buy]
yellow for maybe The Age of Stupid [buy]
red for no Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian [buy]
green for go The Sarah Jane Adventures: The Complete Second Season [buy]
green for go All Creatures Great and Small: Christmas Specials [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.K.)

11.03 (Region 1)
green for go The Taking of Pelham 123 [buy]
green for go Thicker Than Water: The Vampire Diaries Part 1 [buy]
yellow for maybe Food, Inc. [buy]
red for no G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra [buy]
red for no Aliens in the Attic [buy]
red for no I Love You, Beth Cooper [buy]
green for go North by Northwest (50th Anniversary Edition) [buy]
green for go Doctor Who: The War Games [buy]
green for go Doctor Who: The Black Guardian Trilogy [buy]
green for go National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (Ultimate Collector's Edition) [buy]
green for go Mission: Impossible: Complete Series [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.S.)

11.02 (Region 2)
green for go Public Enemies [buy]
yellow for maybe Last Chance Harvey [buy]
red for no Year One [buy]
red for no Blood: The Last Vampire [buy]
green for go Wallace and Gromit: The Complete Collection [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.K.)

my book (Amazon U.S.)

my book (Amazon U.K.)

advertisements

search

Google
flickfilosopher.com
web