obsession boyfriend i'm psyched girl crush i'm dreading enemy

(need an explanation?)

advertisements





when in Stratford-upon-Avon, U.K., I stay at
Adelphi Guest House




reviews Mon Dec 23 02, 6:47PM

Gangs of New York (review)

Forgotten History

(Best of 2002)

New York City has an amazing capacity to absorb the amazing. Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey circus can walk nearly the length of 34th Street -- as I have seen happen -- with cars honking from behind police-car barricades as elephants and camels stroll by, and 5 minutes later, when the traffic starts flowing again and the cops are gone, you'd never know anything extraordinary had happened. The city flows around bumps, smoothes them over, until they are all but forgotten.

The big bumps take longer to wear down -- years or generations, even -- but worn down they are nevertheless. Lower Manhattan can be devastated, citizens horribly killed, the entire city shaken, all with national repercussions, and it will eventually be forgotten to everyone but history geeks. To New Yorkers still shell-shocked by 9/11 -- and we are; there are still local radio and TV ads reminding us that it's okay if we're not feeling better yet, and here's where to get free counseling -- that might seem impossible. But it's happened before.

(more below the ad... scroll down...)

New York in the 1860s was a powder keg of racial, ethnic, and class tensions exacerbated by huge influxes of Irish immigrants escaping the famine, who vied with recently emancipated slaves and other free blacks for low-paying jobs; by an entrenched system of political corruption that allowed the rulers of the city to operate blatantly above the law; and by a conscription plan President Lincoln put into action to replenish Union armies decimated by war in the South. In July 1863, the powder keg exploded in four days of riots, looting, lynchings, beatings, and arson. As many as a thousand people may have been killed... a far greater percentage of the city's population at the time, around 800,000, than the death toll of 9/11 was.

Betcha never knew that. Or maybe it was mentioned in passing in 8th-grade social studies.

Martin Scorsese reminds us with Gangs of New York -- a stunning re-creation not only of period places but also of the period mindset -- how ephemeral even the biggest disasters and the most profound events are in the grand scale of history, even over the relatively short term. As soon as the last person with memory of the time dies, the period is suddenly as remote as the Roman Empire or Egypt's Upper Kingdom. Movies extend our memory, though, especially one so meticulous in its depiction of a time and place lost to us.

The Five Points neighborhood of Manhattan doesn't really exist anymore, but the area -- just north of Foley Square, now the borough's courthouse district -- was, in the 19th century, a notorious slum teeming and vibrant with poor immigrants from all over Europe and China, as well as free blacks, and it was here that the Draft Riots were fermented. But Scorsese (Bringing Out the Dead, GoodFellas) and his screenwriters -- Jay Cocks, Steven Zaillian (Schindler's List), and Kenneth Lonergan (You Can Count on Me), working from a cult 1928 novel by Herbert Asbury -- don't tell us the story of the Draft Riots so much as they show us the atmosphere -- ruthless, unforgiving, mired in dire poverty -- that directly caused the Riots.

Gangs is a classic revenge story: Amsterdam (Leonardo DiCaprio: The Beach, Titanic) returns to Five Points from a long stint in an upstate reform school to avenge the murder of his father, Priest (Liam Neeson: Star Wars: Attack of the Clones, The Haunting), leader of a gang of Irish immigrants, at the hands of Bill the Butcher (Daniel Day-Lewis), leader of a gang of "Natives" (not Indians, merely the descendents of earlier immigrants), when Amsterdam was a small child. But it's the almost alien setting of the tale -- so magnificently brought to life -- that makes the film so tremendously powerful.

The Riots are but a backdrop in the finale of Amsterdam's vengeance, but in bursting forth simultaneously, we're sucked into the atmosphere of the city -- lawless, chaotic, explosive -- through an intense identification with Amsterdam. DiCaprio comes into his own as a mature actor here, fiercely passionate and maintaining a slow burn of rage through Scorsese's epic runtime. And Day-Lewis's terrifying performance as the psychotic Bill is a violent immersion into a city ruled by gangs, not only the Butcher's Natives and other Five Points mobs like the Plug Uglies and the Bowery Boys, but also the political gang of Tammany Hall and Boss Tweed (Jim Broadbent: Moulin Rouge, Bridget Jones's Diary). Even the makeshift police squads and fire brigades of the time were endlessly warring tribes, as Scorsese shows us with his trademark black humor.

The film so overflows with raging, grim fury that while the image of a recently deceased bunny mightn't normally inspire dread in us today, both the terror and the loyalty inspired by Priest's gang, the Dead Rabbits, is clear. When Amsterdam returns to resurrect the Rabbits, scattered and powerless since his father's death, you don't have to know that in the slang of the time, "dead" meant "best" and a "rabbit" was a hooligan to grasp the import of the name and their symbol. Likewise, while it might be difficult to imagine 50,000 New Yorkers violently rioting today, as they did in 1863, Gangs makes it not only perfectly understandable but perfectly reasonable that they would.

This is an immensely potent film, often disturbingly violent, neither of which is unexpected from Scorsese. What is surprising is how relevant he makes a forgotten historical tale, connecting it to us today through a simple final dissolve from Lower Manhattan afire in 1863 to the just-pre-9/11 skyline: This too shall pass, and be forgotten.

viewed at a private screening with an audience of critics
rated R for intense strong violence, sexuality/nudity and language
official site | IMDB
(more below the ad... scroll down...)



who I am


I'm MaryAnn Johanson: writer and ponderer in New York City who drinks too much wine and thinks way too much about such inconsequences as movies, TV, books, and the meaning of life.
[email me]
[become a Facebook fan]
[visit my personal Facebook page]
[follow me on Twitter]
[friend me on MySpace]

FlickFilosopher.com is available on Kindle

• contributor, Film.com
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences
• visit my scratchpad blog, MaryAnnJohanson.com
• read my Doctor Who fan fiction

photo by David Speranza

(postings feed)


top critic on Movie Review Query Engine


as seen on Rotten Tomatoes


member, Online Film Critics Society


member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists

Add to Technorati Favorites

monthly archives

recent screenings and hot movies

just opened (U.S.)
red for no The Twilight Saga: New Moon
yellow for maybe Planet 51
not viewed by me The Blind Side [trailer]
not viewed by me Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans [trailer]
yellow for maybe Broken Embraces
green for go Red Cliff [trailer]
yellow for maybe The Missing Person [trailer]
green for go Precious (expanding)
green for go Fantastic Mr. Fox (expanding)
just opened (U.K.)
red for no The Twilight Saga: New Moon
green for go A Serious Man
green for go The Informant!
box office top 5 (U.S.)
yellow for maybe 2012
red for no A Christmas Carol
green for go Precious
green for go The Men Who Stare at Goats
yellow for maybe Michael Jackson's This Is It
top limited releases (U.S.)
green for go Precious
red for no The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day
green for go An Education
green for go A Serious Man
yellow for maybe Coco Before Chanel
box office top 5 (U.K.)
yellow for maybe 2012
red for no A Christmas Carol
not viewed by me Harry Brown
green for go Up
green for go The Men Who Stare at Goats
coming soon (U.S./U.K.)
red for no The Loss of a Teardrop Diamond
yellow for maybe Serious Moonlight [trailer]
yellow for maybe A Single Man [trailer]
green for go Everybody's Fine [trailer]
red for no The Strip
green for go The Private Lives of Pippa Lee [trailer]
green for go The Young Victoria [trailer]
green for go Creation [trailer]
green for go The Road [trailer]
green for go The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus [trailer]
other current flicks (U.S./U.K.)
green for go Amelia
red for no Antichrist [trailer]
red for no Astro Boy
yellow for maybe The Box
green for go The Boys Are Back
green for go Bright Star
green for go Capitalism: A Love Story [trailer]
yellow for maybe Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant
yellow for maybe Collapse
red for no Couples Retreat
green for go Creation [trailer]
green for go The Damned United
green for go An Education
green for go Five Minutes of Heaven
yellow for maybe The Fourth Kind
red for no Gentlemen Broncos [trailer]
green for go The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus [trailer]
green for go The Invention of Lying
red for no Jennifer's Body
green for go The Messenger [trailer]
green for go Ong Bak 2: The Beginning
yellow for maybe Paranormal Activity
red for no Pirate Radio (aka The Boat That Rocked)
yellow for maybe A Single Man [trailer]
yellow for maybe Where the Wild Things Are
red for no Whiteout
red for no Women in Trouble
green for go Zombieland

2009 screening log

new on dvd

11.17 (Region 1)
green for go Star Trek [buy]
green for go Humpday [buy]
green for go Bruno [buy]
green for go Is Anybody There? [buy]
yellow for maybe The Limits of Control [buy]
yellow for maybe My Sister's Keeper [buy]
yellow for maybe How to Be [buy]
green for go Farscape: The Complete Series [buy]
green for go Gone with the Wind: 70th Anniversary Ultimate Collector's Edition [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.S.)

11.16 (Region 2)
green for go Star Trek [buy]
green for go Moon [buy]
green for go Sunshine Cleaning [buy]
yellow for maybe Four Christmases [buy]
yellow for maybe Tyson [buy]
green for go An Evening with John Barrowman [buy]
green for go Doctor Who: The Key to Time [buy]
green for go South Park: Christmas Time in South Park [buy]
green for go Star Trek Trilogy [buy]
green for go Star Trek: The Next Generation Movie Collection [buy]
green for go Star Trek: Films 1-10 Remastered Special Edition [buy]
yellow for maybe Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season 2 [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.K.)

11.10 (Region 1)
green for go Up [buy]
red for no The Ugly Truth [buy]
green for go The Sarah Jane Adventures: The Complete Second Season [buy]
green for go Ink [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.S.)

11.09 (Region 2)
green for go Bruno [buy]
yellow for maybe The Age of Stupid [buy]
red for no Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian [buy]
green for go The Sarah Jane Adventures: The Complete Second Season [buy]
green for go All Creatures Great and Small: Christmas Specials [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.K.)

11.03 (Region 1)
green for go The Taking of Pelham 123 [buy]
green for go Thicker Than Water: The Vampire Diaries Part 1 [buy]
yellow for maybe Food, Inc. [buy]
red for no G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra [buy]
red for no Aliens in the Attic [buy]
red for no I Love You, Beth Cooper [buy]
green for go North by Northwest (50th Anniversary Edition) [buy]
green for go Doctor Who: The War Games [buy]
green for go Doctor Who: The Black Guardian Trilogy [buy]
green for go National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (Ultimate Collector's Edition) [buy]
green for go Mission: Impossible: Complete Series [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.S.)

11.02 (Region 2)
green for go Public Enemies [buy]
yellow for maybe Last Chance Harvey [buy]
red for no Year One [buy]
red for no Blood: The Last Vampire [buy]
green for go Wallace and Gromit: The Complete Collection [buy]
(complete list of this week's new releases at Amazon U.K.)

my book (Amazon U.S.)

my book (Amazon U.K.)

advertisements

search

Google
flickfilosopher.com
web