obsession boyfriend i'm psyched     i'm dreading enemy

(need an explanation?)

advertisements


over at Film.com...

I’m still plugging away over at Film.com, at least twice a day. Recent stuff you may have missed:

the new and improved TiVo This!

I preview Wednesday movie releases

I take on a promo for Fox’s new TV series Drive

British SF fans vote for Serenity as best SF film evah -- chaos ensues

Russell Crowe to play Sherlock Holmes? cool!

my usual Monday weekend wrapup

Feel free to use this as an open thread to discuss my Film.com stuff.


more below the ad... scroll down...



comments

Regarding the "best sci-fi movie ever" poll:

Polls have a notorious bias towards the recent. I remember being told of a poll for best song ever that "Kung Fu Fighting" one- said poll being taken while that song was a big hit. 2001 is number 8? Yeah. I suppose the result does say something about the strength of the Firefly fandom, but I wouldn't be overly impressed even if the fans didn't cheat the poll so blatantly.

I don't think Star Wars should ever be included in a list of best sci-fi movies, though. I love the original trilogy (the prequels had their moments, but overall they were a huge let-down, but that's another argument altogether), but it is not science fiction. Clearly, Lucas and others weren't concerned about making plausible science fiction. They weren't telling a story about the future of human evolution or warning us of the dangerous path we were on. Star Wars is a romantic space opera. It's about exciting stories and characters that draw you in and make you forget the world. It has no connection to reality and does not attempt to seem like a plausible story. It exists in its own world with its own rules. That makes it more fantasy than science fiction. That's not an insult by any means. I just think they're comparing apples to oranges.

post a comment

who I am


I'm MaryAnn Johanson: writer and ponderer in New York City who drinks too much wine and thinks way too much about such inconsequences as movies, TV, books, and the meaning of life.
[email me]

• contributor, Film.com
• member, Online Film Critics Society
• member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences
• visit my scratchpad blog, MaryAnnJohanson.com
• read my Doctor Who fan fiction

photo by David Speranza

(postings feed)

Add to Technorati Favorites

monthly archives

recent screenings and hot movies

just opened
yellow for maybe Diminished Capacity
yellow for maybe The Wackness
green for go Hancock
green for go Kit Kittredge: An American Girl
box office top 5
green for go Wall-E
green for go Wanted
yellow for maybe Get Smart
green for go Kung Fu Panda
green for go The Incredible Hulk
top limited releases
green for go Mongol
green for go The Visitor
When Did You Last See Your Father?
green for go Kit Kittredge: An American Girl
Then She Found Me
coming soon
green for go Man on Wire
yellow for maybe Journey to the Center of the Earth 3D
red for no Harold
yellow for maybe Hellboy II: The Golden Army
red for no Fly Me to the Moon
yellow for maybe A Thousand Years of Good Prayers
now playing
red for no The Love Guru
red for no The Happening
yellow for maybe You Don't Mess With the Zohan
green for go Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
green for go The Fall
green for go Young@Heart
yellow for maybe Quid Pro Quo
red for no Sex and the City: The Movie
red for no The Strangers
green for go Dreams With Sharp Teeth
green for go Iron Man
green for go The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian

2008 screening log

advertisements

search

Google
flickfilosopher.com
web
Powered by
Movable Type 3.36