dream cast: hypothetical ‘Simon & Simon’ movie

We tried this last week, and it was a lot of fun, so I’m continuing to test this as a regular Thursday feature. We take a book to adapt to TV or film -- or a movie or TV show to remake -- and we recast it with actors working today.

It’s another great 80s show this time: Simon & Simon, the 1981-8 CBS dramedy detective series about two brothers, Rick and A.J., who run a PI agency in San Diego.

Gerald McRaney played Rick, the older brother: he’s an ex-Marine Vietnam vet and a bit rough-and-tumble; he drives a pickup truck, wears a cowboy hat, and is generally the life of the party. Jameson Parker was A.J., who is smoother and more sophisticated, likes books and wine, dresses fashionably, and drives a Camaro. Mary Carver played their mother, Cecilia, who was pretty spunky and got into plenty of trouble of her own. And Tim Reid played Downtown Brown, a police detective who sometimes threw work the boys’ way, and sometimes helped them out on cases.

I have two dream casts -- one if a movie stuck with the series’ dramedy spin, and one if it went more goofy.

Dramedy dream cast:

Rick: Josh Lucas
A.J.: Matthew Fox
Cecilia: Judi Dench
Downtown Brown: Don Cheadle

Goofy dream cast:

Rick: Luke Wilson
A.J.: Owen Wilson
Cecilia: Christine Baranski
Downtown Brown: Chris Rock

Who would you cast? Have fun!

This one had a catchy theme, too (though one without lyrics to get stuck in your head all day):

support


pre-Disqus comments

The quick-fire comedy answer is Dr.Phil and David Spade, however...

Rick: Nathan Fillion

AJ: Jason Bateman

Cecilia: Blythe Danner

Brown: Mos Def


Next up, The Rockford files re-cast...David Boreanaz in a plaid jacket and chest high trousers!

I forgot to add that MaryAnn's inclusion of Owen Wilson makes me think of his turn in "The Big Bounce" which had a very "updated" Magnum PI vibe to it (even though it wasn't very good) which, as we sad 30ish folk know, was the lead in for Simon & Simon for many years.

Rick: Woody Harrelson
A.J.: Vince Vaughn
Cecilia: Bea Arthur
Downtown Brown: Can't beat Don Cheadle

Though I think the brotherly pairing of Fillion and Bateman is a hell of an idea.

Rick: Nathan Fillion AJ: Jason Bateman Brown: Mos Def

Yes! All much better than mine.

Rick: Nathan Fillion/Adam Baldwin (let there be twins!)
A.J.: Sean Maher
Cecelia: Bonnie Bartlett
Downtown Brown: Ron Glass (this would be a dignified Downtown Brown, you know)

Also, you can watch eps of S&S at Hulu! I stumbled across them when I checked out the site after watching Dr. Horrible.

http://www.hulu.com/simon-and-simon

You forgot about Janet and Myron!!!

Dramedy dream cast:

Rick: Josh Brolin
A.J.: Jared Leto
Cecilia: Helen Mirren
Downtown Brown: Samuel L. Jackson

Goofy dream cast:

Rick: Bruce Campbell
A.J.: David Hyde Pierce
Cecilia: Holly Hunter
Downtown Brown: Samuel L. Jackson

Dramedy dream cast:

Rick: Josh Brolin
A.J.: Jared Leto
Cecilia: Helen Mirren
Downtown Brown: Samuel L. Jackson

Goofy dream cast:

Rick: Bruce Campbell
A.J.: David Hyde Pierce
Cecilia: Holly Hunter
Downtown Brown: Samuel L. Jackson

Disqus comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

  
posted:
Thu Aug 07 08, 8:30AM

categories:
talent buzz




9 pre-Disqus comments
Disqus comments


tip jar





share


 
 


read more




related


· dream cast: hypothetical ‘Lethal Weapon’ remake
· dream cast: hypothetical ‘Ferris Bueller’s Day Off’ remake
· dream cast: hypothetical ‘Remington Steele’ movie
· dream cast: hypothetical ‘A-Team’ movie
· dream cast: hypothetical ‘Back to the Future’ remake
· dream cast: hypothetical ‘Greatest American Hero’ movie


bloggy


previous post:
‘Doctor Who’ blogging: “Journey’s End”

next post:
latest contest winners

search




search FlickFilosopher.com


follow

  
  
  
(in case of site outages or other emergencies, I'll update my status on Twitter and Facebook)



Get our toolbar!

follow FlickFilosopher.com no matter where you are online


share and enjoy

shop to support

support FlickFilosopher.com when you click through here and buy almost anything at:

Amazon U.S.
Amazon Canada
Amazon U.K.
Amazon Germany
Amazon France
Amazon Spain
Amazon Italy
Chapters/Indigo (Canada)