Nice name calling. If you can't state a specific criticism of Michael Medved, maybe you shouldn't say anything at all. You people make liberals look bad.
Seriously, though, it's Michael Medved - this is a fellow of the Discovery Institute. This is someone who thinks the Coen brothers are antisemitic, but Mel Gibson isn't. This is someone who wrote a book about how Hollywood was alienating Middle America with films like The Silence of the Lambs and Se7en which were, er, massive, massive hits. This is someone who got bent out of shape over possible gay content in Sherlock Holmes about half a year before it came out. You can't engage him in criticism on his substantial points because he doesn't have any substantial points. If you can't joke about him, who can you joke about?
Nice name calling. If you can't state a specific criticism of Michael Medved, maybe you shouldn't say anything at all. You people make liberals look bad.
Point taken. Some of his views are morally icky. (Though it would have been nice if you followed some of those claims up with a link, Paul.)
I'm no fan of Michael Medved and I once argued on a now-deceased film forum that he has a habit of writing stuff in such a way that even if you agree with him, you'd rather not admit it. (Call him a disciple of the Dr. Laura Schlesinger School of Film Criticism if you will.)
But still...a serial killer?
I'm hoping Colbert's quote was a lot funnier in its original context because it doesn't seem that funny from here...
Oh, sorry. I just googled the guy's name and followed it to Wikipedia.
If you are talking about "Dr. Laura" the radio personality, I believe she did say one wise thing: what happens is morally gray if you are doing it, it is black and white if it is happening to you.
pre-Disqus comments
posted by PaulW (Mon Apr 06 09, 11:40PM)
Medved is still around? I thought we got him sent to the insane asylum years ago for his crimes against humanity.
posted by Hank Graham (Tue Apr 07 09, 2:35AM)
And I think that's a scandalous libel of the deranged homicidal hitchhiker community (to paraphrase Firefly)
posted by Rick (Sat Dec 26 09, 2:55AM)
Nice name calling. If you can't state a specific criticism of Michael Medved, maybe you shouldn't say anything at all. You people make liberals look bad.
posted by Der Bruno Stroszek (Sat Dec 26 09, 5:21AM)
Your concern is noted.
Seriously, though, it's Michael Medved - this is a fellow of the Discovery Institute. This is someone who thinks the Coen brothers are antisemitic, but Mel Gibson isn't. This is someone who wrote a book about how Hollywood was alienating Middle America with films like The Silence of the Lambs and Se7en which were, er, massive, massive hits. This is someone who got bent out of shape over possible gay content in Sherlock Holmes about half a year before it came out. You can't engage him in criticism on his substantial points because he doesn't have any substantial points. If you can't joke about him, who can you joke about?
posted by Tonio Kruger (Sat Dec 26 09, 2:40PM)
I believe a most apt response would be "So?"
posted by Tonio Kruger (Sat Dec 26 09, 2:42PM)
Er, I mean a more apt response to the original comment would be "So?"
My brain keeps outrunning my fingers...
posted by Paul (Sat Dec 26 09, 5:41PM)
So I went looking for specific critizisms.
1: He joined the Discovery Institute which promotes intelligent design.
2: He wrote a column defending slavery.
That's pretty much enough for me to write anyone off.
posted by Tonio Kruger (Sun Dec 27 09, 3:12PM)
Point taken. Some of his views are morally icky. (Though it would have been nice if you followed some of those claims up with a link, Paul.)
I'm no fan of Michael Medved and I once argued on a now-deceased film forum that he has a habit of writing stuff in such a way that even if you agree with him, you'd rather not admit it. (Call him a disciple of the Dr. Laura Schlesinger School of Film Criticism if you will.)
But still...a serial killer?
I'm hoping Colbert's quote was a lot funnier in its original context because it doesn't seem that funny from here...
posted by Paul (Sun Dec 27 09, 4:48PM)
Oh, sorry. I just googled the guy's name and followed it to Wikipedia.
If you are talking about "Dr. Laura" the radio personality, I believe she did say one wise thing: what happens is morally gray if you are doing it, it is black and white if it is happening to you.
Or words to that effect.