question of the day: What will the five nominees for Best Animated Feature Film be?The 20 pictures in contention for five nominee slots -- up from three in recent years -- for the upcoming Academy Awards in the Best Animated Feature Film category have been announced. They are: Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel (Films I haven’t seen appear in italics.) What will the five nominees for Best Animated Feature Film be? Note that a prediction of which films Oscar will honor with a nomination is not the same thing as choosing which films you think are the best of the year, so if your favorites are different, feel free to share your favorites as well. I think, based on what I have seen so far (combined with guesses about what I haven’t seen), that the Oscar nominees will be (alphabetical): Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs If I were ranking the top 5 best animated films of the year (that I’ve seen so far, of course), they’d be: Up (If you have a suggestion for a QOTD, feel free to email me. Responses to this QOTD sent by email will be ignored; please post your responses here.) Disqus commentsblog comments powered by Disqus |
posted:
Tue Nov 17 09, 7:53AM categories: awards buzz talk amongst yourselves permalink 7 pre-Disqus comments Disqus comments tip jarshare
read more
9
Alvin and the Chipmunks The Squeakquel Astro Boy Battle for Terra Christmas Carol Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs Coraline Disney Dolphin Story of a Dreamer Fantastic Mr Fox Ice Age Dawn of the Dinosaurs Mary and Max Missing Lynx Monsters vs Aliens Oscars Planet 51 Ponyo Princess and the Frog qotd Secret of Kells Tinker Bell and the Lost Treasure Town Called Panic Up related· question of the day: Is this the greatest year ever for animated films? · Oscar predictions: ‘The Hurt Locker’ won’t be hurting · U.K. box office: And ‘Avatar’ is back at the top · my week at the movies: ‘Inglourious Basterds,’ ‘District 9’ (again), ‘9,’ ‘Shorts,’ ‘Bandslam,’ ‘Fifty Dead Men Walking,’ ‘The Goods: Live Hard, Sell Hard,’ ‘Ponyo,’ ‘Paper Heart’ (maybe) · totally quotable! 2009 · U.K. box office: ‘A Christmas Carol’ not so jolly · question of the day: What are the odds that at least one 2009 nominee for Best Picture came out of Comic Con? · Ponyo (review) · August 14: DVD alternatives to this weekend’s multiplex offerings · caption this! image from ‘Ponyo’ bloggyprevious post: my week at the movies: ‘The Twilight Saga: New Moon,’ ‘Serious Moonlight,’ ‘Planet 51,’ ‘Brothers,’ ‘The Loss of a Teardrop Diamond’ next post: the oh-no! DVD of the week: ‘ThanksKilling’ |









pre-Disqus comments
posted by Hank Graham (Tue Nov 17 09, 12:40PM)
And the nominees will be Ponyo and Up and some others.
Which is as it should be, when you think about it.
posted by bats :[ (Tue Nov 17 09, 3:14PM)
Geez...were there any animated features that WEREN'T nominated this year? This looks like a T-ball roster -- everyone gets a pat on the back and a cookie.
posted by Jurgan (Tue Nov 17 09, 3:28PM)
Look again, Bats- she said those were the eligible movies. So the list would be pretty thorough. Only five will actually be nominated.
The only ones I've seen, I think, were Coraline and Up, but they were both good enough to deserve it.
posted by JosephFM (Tue Nov 17 09, 10:39PM)
I'd agree, for sure, with Fantastic Mr. Fox, Up, and Coraline.
But it's also possible that The Princess & the Frog could get in over Cloudy, 9 or Ponyo. I'm not one to underestimate a Disney princess.
posted by PaulW (Tue Nov 17 09, 11:22PM)
Ponyo might not be nominated: the critics were underwhelmed and I don't think it was a huge hit at the box office.
The stop-motion type films like Fox, 9 and Coraline would receive greater consideration than the CGI ones, if only because CGI seems more prevalent.
Up is practically a given. If Up goes for Best Picture overall, would it also get a dual nod in the Animated category?
My personal choices would have to be:
Up (ought to win)
Coraline
Fantastic Mr. Fox
Aliens vs. Monsters
Cloudy with a Chance for Meatballs
Question: are Coraline, Fox, and Cloudy up for Best Adapted Screenplay noms? That would be interesting to see...
posted by markyd (Wed Nov 18 09, 9:14AM)
Out of that list, I only saw Up, 9, and Coraline. I liked all of them, although I do think Up is a tad overrated.
I'd to see all three of them nominated. I'm not qualified to pick any others, but my guess would be Cloudy(due to its good reviews and public reception) and Mr. Fox. It just looks so unique compared to everything else. I can imagine Ponyo squeezing one of those out, though.
Up will win.
posted by par3182 (Thu Nov 19 09, 9:05AM)
coraline
fantastic mr fox
mary and max (don't underestimate this one)
the princess and the frog
up