obsession boyfriend i'm psyched girl crush i'm dreading enemy

advertisements




support FlickFilosopher.com
when you click through here
and buy almost anything at:

Amazon U.S.

Amazon Canada

Amazon U.K.






when in Stratford-upon-Avon, U.K., I stay at
Adelphi Guest House




question of the day: Is geek culture female friendly?

Echoing a question that Jezebel asked earlier this week: Is geek culture female friendly?

The answer, whatever it may be, goes well beyond whether there are lots of women at science fiction conventions (as was pointed out by commenters in this recent thread about how many men are astonished to learn that a woman likes science fiction). Women make up the majority of moviegoers, a larger majority than we are in the general population (as I noted in last week’s Week in Women column), but that doesn’t necessarily mean that Teh Movies are necessarily female friendly.

(more below the ad... scroll down...)

What attracted me to geek culture originally, when I was a kid, was certainly not female friendly. Girls and women were not much beyond tokens in the SF that I read or watched on TV or saw in the the movies, and that’s mostly still true today... though some in-roads are being made, particularly with shows such as Battlestar Galactica and Caprica. Still, women are no better represented in the genre than they are in the entertainment universe overall. The literature is a lot more inclusive than it was in the 1970s, but while videogaming may be enjoyed by lots of women, it’s also sadly lacking in representations of women (see: this bullsht excuse as to why there are no female soldiers in battle games).

And as for the fans themselves... there may be lots of women who are into geek stuff, and lots of women who attend SF conventions, but I’ve certainly encountered more than a few geek guys who still don’t value a woman’s opinion as much as they value a man’s, who will interrupt a woman who’s speaking but will let a man talk on, and so on. Not all men, of course, but the incidence of sexist, clueless jerks doesn’t seem to be much less among geeks than among the general population.

What do you think: Is geek culture female friendly?

(If you have a suggestion for a QOTD, feel free to email me. Responses to this QOTD sent by email will be ignored; please post your responses here.)



       
submit to reddit

see everything else tagged: Battlestar Galactica | Caprica | geek philosophy | Jezebel | qotd | Week in Women
(more below the ad... scroll down...)



comments

As the number of creators of geekery - comics, sci-fi pulp, fantasy novels, etc. - expanded to include women, I'd definitely say that it's gotten female-friendlier.

As best I recall my pop culture history studies, a lot of the early scifi/fantasy was dominated by male writers and artists, which tended to pander to male tastes (Dejah Thoris, anyone?). When the markets expanded in the 50s and 60s to include women creators like Le Guin (and even Trek pulp by Diane Duane), you saw some shifting to more gender-complex materials. The comics industry in particular over the last 15 years has seen more women as artists and writers, which is where I think more of the female-fan-friendlier stuff has been happening.

I'd still say it's 70/30 male/female orientation in the geek markets, but it's getting there.

As a Late Gen X Geek Girl who's hung out with geek boys ever since she found a critical mass of them in high school/college, and who's been married to a geek for almost 10 years, I would say a "qualified yes".

Yes, because geek males worth knowing are more welcoming to/interested in an intelligent gal who gets their jokes, understands what he did at work/school that day, embraces/shares the social quirks that made their formative social lives miserable, and can match them zing for zing. Also Yes because of the trends in Geek Pop Culture mentioned above by Paul. Finally, the male/female ratio in geekdom is rather skewed, but more so these days because many younger girls hide their lights under bushels to fit in, and get sucked into conformity. That in turn makes the straight geek girl highly prized as a friend or companion in geek culture, at least to men with taste. (and is there any other kind of man worth knowing, geek or no?)

Qualified because, well, let's be blunt--even the best geek males can be diamonds in the rough into their late 20s. Guys mature slower than ladies as a rule, and geek guys even more so, for a variety of reasons. Many geeks of my acquaintance really don't think they mastered adulthood until their late 20s. On the flip side, geek girls tend to mature at about the average speed, if not faster. Also, there are incurable male doofuses in every IQ bracket. I dunno if there are more of them in geekdom, so much as they don't have the social know-how to keep it roped in at first. Of course, The definition of "geek" I use includes the ability to interact with a female on an equal plane, however awkwardly. Any guy worth knowing, geek or no, has learned or will swiftly learn this skill.

I think geek girls have to make their own path in geek culture, and that sometimes there are obstacles or stupid misconceptions to be dealt with. However, I think as a rule the intelligent female has a MUCH harder time of it in 'mundane' society, and that the Geek subculture is getting more female-friendly by the day.

I dunno but most of my tv heroines come from "geek" culture - Scully, Starbuck, Ro Laren, etc

As someone who has been trying to make a go of it as a SF/F writer, I have to say yes. If I was the kind of guy who didn't respect women's professional opinions, I'd be in a world of hurt dealing with editors, agents, and fellow writers, given the numbers of them who are women. Sexism in the publishing world mostly comes from the sales guys, who are usually more interesting in the marketing side. You know, the sort of guys who cancel "Firefly" or are neutering the SF channel; they are not geeks.

This is not to deny the clueless sexism on the part of some men mentioned above, but rather to point out the oppertunities for women in geek culture.

I don't think geek culture is particularly anybody friendly. In many ways it accepts all because it holds almost everything with the same level of self-critical disdain warring with obsessive love. To paraphrase Kevin Smith (badly and from faulty memory) geeks are the only people who will show up to a convention wearing a replica stormtrooper costume, run into a guy wearing a perfect Spock costume and deride him for being a fucking nerd with a straight face.

You must be willing to defend your passions and in return you will be instantly accepted by anyone else who shares them. And if you can't stand the heat you will not be very welcome.

I happened across this a while ago:
http://girl-wonder.org/girlsreadcomics/?p=202

It's all about sexism at comic conventions. There was more crossblogging about it somewhere else, but I can't remember where (some sites seem to have moved).
I saw something similar about game conventions a few years back as well, but E3 has toned down their hollywood aspects for one.

I'm not sure if it relates to the question specifically but the crux seems to be that if you get models dressed up in tight and minimal clothes whose job it is to be nice while putting up with lustful attention (or even encourage it), this environment gets at least a subset of males thinking it applies to every girl there is at the event. This we can state with some confidence. That then might discourage females from turning up and so forth.

There was a bit of a dust up a while ago over at Scienceblogs and in the Skeptic-o-sphere in general over how male dominated and faintly boys club the whole thing can be, particularly at conferences and other get togethers (there was one set of talks in particular used to illustrate that the speakers were only talking to the men in the audience and making lad-ish jokes etc. I can't remember which one. But these are old academics we're talking about, not maladjusted fifteen year olds or whatever). From memory there was some overlap with debate amongst the female contingent over how brassy and crude (or, as I would term it: funny) and even underdressed some of the girls are and whether or not that was bad for females in skepticism etc etc. So that one's still around too.

It's still very much a hot topic that will flare up from time to time, is all I'm saying.
It's hard to say for sure but much of geek culture strikes me as some of the worst encalves of male stupidity and the most alienating to women. That could be just because it's what I know, but I think you'd have an easier time if you were a female metalhead or gearhead than sci-fi fan or whatever.

I think that depends a lot on what you think geek culture is. Some folks seem to think that's university engineering departments and others think it's what gets sold as geek collectables or whether video games are cooperative. What I think of as geek cultures is different enough than what someone else thinks of as geek culture that we'd probably have to start by defining terms.

But all in all I think there are great people and jerks to be found in most environments. If some fan boy gets rude when a girl or woman is around that's on him and not the group he'd like to think he has some kind of status in. It's not because he's a geek. It's because he's a jerk.

post a comment

who I am


I'm MaryAnn Johanson: writer and ponderer in New York City who drinks too much wine and thinks way too much about such inconsequences as movies, TV, books, and the meaning of life.
[email me] [MaryAnnJohanson.com]

nominee: BEST ONLINE CRITIC, 2010 National Entertainment Journalism Awards (Los Angeles Press Club)

[become a Facebook fan]
[visit my personal Facebook page]
[follow me on Twitter]
[give me whuffie]

FlickFilosopher.com is available on Kindle

• contributor, Film.com
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences
• read my Doctor Who fan fiction

photo by David Speranza

(postings feed)


featured critic on Movie Review Intelligence


top critic on Movie Review Query Engine


as seen on Rotten Tomatoes


member, Online Film Critics Society


member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists

Large Association of Movie Blogs

Add to Technorati Favorites

Local Directory for New York, New York

monthly archives

recent screenings and hot movies

opening 07.30 (U.S./Canada)
red for no Dinner for Schmucks
yellow for maybe Charlie St. Cloud
not seen by me Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore [trailer]
green for go The Concert [trailer]
yellow for maybe The Dry Land [trailer]
green for go The Extra Man [trailer]
green for go Smash His Camera [trailer]
green for go The Kids Are All Right (expanding)
not seen by me Winter's Bone [trailer] (expanding)
opening 07.28-30 (U.K.)
red for no The Karate Kid
green for go The A-Team
not seen by me Beautiful Kate [trailer]
not seen by me South of the Border
box office 07.23-07.25 (U.S./Canada)
green for go Inception
green for go Salt
green for go Despicable Me
red for no The Sorcerer's Apprentice
green for go Toy Story 3
box office 07.23-07.25 (U.K.)
green for go Toy Story 3
green for go Inception
red for no The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
yellow for maybe Shrek Forever After
not seen by me The Rebound [trailer]
opening soon
red for no Scott Pilgrim vs. the World [trailer]
other current flicks
green for go Agora [trailer]
not seen by me Black Death [trailer]
green for go City Island
green for go Countdown to Zero [trailer]
red for no Cyrus
yellow for maybe Get Him to the Greek
yellow for maybe The Girl Who Played with Fire [trailer]
green for go The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
yellow for maybe Greenberg [trailer]
red for no Grown Ups
green for go Harry Brown
green for go Hubble 3D [trailer]
red for no The Human Centipede
red for no I Am Love
red for no Jonah Hex
not seen by me The Killer Inside Me [trailer]
red for no Killers
red for no Knight and Day
red for no The Last Airbender
yellow for maybe Letters to Juliet
green for go The Losers
red for no MacGruber
red for no Marmaduke
green for go Micmacs
yellow for maybe Mother and Child
not seen by me The Nature of Existence [trailer]
yellow for maybe Ondine [trailer]
green for go Orlando (rerelease)
yellow for maybe Predators
red for no Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
yellow for maybe Princess Kaiulani [trailer]
yellow for maybe [REC] 2 [trailer]
red for no Robin Hood
green for go Ramona and Beezus
green for go The Secret in Their Eyes
red for no Sex and the City 2
red for no She's Out of My League
red for no Solitary Man
red for no Splice
yellow for maybe Valhalla Rising [trailer]
green for go Whatever Works [trailer]
red for no When in Rome
green for go When You're Strange
not seen by me Wild Target [trailer]

2010 screening log

new on dvd

advertisements

search

Google
flickfilosopher.com
web