If you want to jump in to watching Doctor Who but you’ve never seen it before and you’re worried you’re be all confused and lost, check out io9’s “Everything You Need To Know About Doctor Who” (via reader Keith).
Oh. My. Word. 10/10. Steven Moffat is a genius. I've seen all the trailers and spoilers and interviews and plot summaries and I was still surprised and delighted. It was amazing.
I'm really bummed that I missed it. I normally watch a live stream of it, but I was out all afternoon. I can't find a stream of it, so I have to be patient and wait few weeks to watch it. (I'm not a Torrent fan).
Sadly, I think I'm going to have to wait for the legal television broadcast in this country, but I hear that David Tennant will be on PBS this Wednesday. Some play set in Denmark.
Found this link for all of us fans so we can be watched it as it's being aired!! Or watch recently aired episodes. I run Google chrome specifically for this purpose.
Good episode bit of a flat cliff-hanger could have ended it 5 seconds before and it would have been better. I haven't liked this series so far but it seems to have caught fire with this one
Loved River, Pond, bizarre Skinner cameo, angels - it was class!
After the philosophical arguments that have been occurring on other threads, it did seem a bit surprising to see a certain surprise element appear in this one. And was this episode's villain actually changing its m.o. from times past? Maybe that was just me.
That said, I can't rightly judge this week's episode until I see what happens next week.
There's a fair bit of Amy bashing going on on UK TV chatsites at the moment, which is beginning to get on my nerves. One poster referred to her as 'immodest' after her reaction to a particularly brilliant solution she thought up in this episode, which nearly made my head explode. Would anyone have referred to a male character as 'immodest'?
Look on the bright side - those of us watching on BBC1 had all the tension punctured by a stupid, bright orange ident for the next programme popping up right on top of the Doctor as he made that great speech about traps.
I adore the BBC, but sometimes it really shoots itself in the foot. There has been something of a hoo-hah about this...
^ yeah I couldn't figure that one out myself - was I too engrossed in the episode to notice? But they only showed it in England. Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland were cartoon Graham Norton free.
I'm not sure if it's Karen bashing or Amy bashing. I find that it's too early to tell if she's a good actress.
Heh - my Sky+ went phooey and didn't record it, so I ended up watching it on the BBC iPlayer, and no silly orange thing.
Actually, those banner things are what I find incredibly irritating if I'm watching American TV and it's really really not something we should be copying!
Lisa, I've not seen so much Karen bashing - it's mostly people whining about Amy being cocky and how very dare she talk to Churchill like that. . .etc. I think the accusation running underneath is that the character is somehow 'unfeminine', which is what is winding me up.
Yes, because god forbid that a girl should question the way men run the world! I've always (well, since he's turned up on Confidential discussing the scripts) had a teensy crush on Stephen Moffat, but am in danger of it becoming a proper infatuation if he keeps this up.
Amy's a great companion and a fabulous role model - I can only hope my Who-loving daughter (5) grows up like her!
The 2nd time I watched, I was wondering why we had the opening scene with the dazed man in the field. He was drugged and had River's lipstick on his face. That reminded me of when John Hart kissed Gwen! Is River a time agent?
@Max I think he was some type of a security guard I thought it was quite surreal cos I was thinking that looks like The Streets! and it was him !weird! it looked like one of his videos too.
See I think Amy's a great companion but I don't know if Karen can act yet. I know Matt can act because I have seen him in other things. I'm not 100% sold on him or her. I have seen blogs, forums, etc, which criticise her acting style i.e. pouting and then the wide eyed stare.
pre-Disqus comments
posted by Max (Sat Apr 24 10, 1:57PM)
You're watching it right now, aren't you?
posted by MaryAnn (Sat Apr 24 10, 2:39PM)
Wish I could. Must wait for the largesse of the Internet to provide...
posted by Les Carr (Sat Apr 24 10, 2:52PM)
Oh. My. Word. 10/10. Steven Moffat is a genius. I've seen all the trailers and spoilers and interviews and plot summaries and I was still surprised and delighted. It was amazing.
posted by Martin (Sat Apr 24 10, 2:57PM)
Careful Les Carr, spoilers! ;)
But yeah, definitely a good one.
posted by Isobel (Sat Apr 24 10, 3:58PM)
I concur! Very relieved, too - wasn't impressed by last week but it's very much back on track. Phew!
posted by Jo the Hat (Sat Apr 24 10, 4:17PM)
Spoilers indeed - but I'm falling deeper in love with Doctor Who each week. And I NEVER dreamed that was possible in a post-Tennant era. And I mean it about the spoilers...
posted by Martin (Sat Apr 24 10, 4:38PM)
Agreed Jo.
And I'm really falling in love with Amy. She's smart, brave and silly when she needs to be.
posted by Jo the Hat (Sat Apr 24 10, 5:03PM)
You're not alone in your admiration for Amy, Martin. I'm actually enjoying watching it without crushing on the Doctor. I'm saving all my inappropriate feelings for the Gene Genie!
posted by Alli (Sat Apr 24 10, 10:01PM)
I'm really bummed that I missed it. I normally watch a live stream of it, but I was out all afternoon. I can't find a stream of it, so I have to be patient and wait few weeks to watch it. (I'm not a Torrent fan).
posted by Mo (Sat Apr 24 10, 11:03PM)
Wow. I don't think I've gotten the heebie jeebies off of a TV show like that ever. *shudders*
posted by Kenny (Sun Apr 25 10, 10:11AM)
I know what you mean Mo, there was a real "oh SHIT!" moment or two right there.
posted by Daniel (Sun Apr 25 10, 1:20PM)
Sadly, I think I'm going to have to wait for the legal television broadcast in this country, but I hear that David Tennant will be on PBS this Wednesday. Some play set in Denmark.
posted by Max (Sun Apr 25 10, 3:56PM)
Found this link for all of us fans so we can be watched it as it's being aired!! Or watch recently aired episodes. I run Google chrome specifically for this purpose.
http://lifehacker.com/5504681/how-to-access-the-bbc-iplayer-and-tv-like-doctor-who-from-outside-the-uk?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+lifehacker%2Ffull+(Lifehacker)
This proxy 92.52.125.20 works on port 80.
posted by Alli (Sun Apr 25 10, 6:07PM)
Thank you Max! Loved the episode.
posted by Lisa (Sun Apr 25 10, 9:48PM)
Good episode bit of a flat cliff-hanger could have ended it 5 seconds before and it would have been better. I haven't liked this series so far but it seems to have caught fire with this one
Loved River, Pond, bizarre Skinner cameo, angels - it was class!
posted by Tonio Kruger (Mon Apr 26 10, 12:29AM)
After the philosophical arguments that have been occurring on other threads, it did seem a bit surprising to see a certain surprise element appear in this one. And was this episode's villain actually changing its m.o. from times past? Maybe that was just me.
That said, I can't rightly judge this week's episode until I see what happens next week.
posted by Isobel (Mon Apr 26 10, 3:46AM)
There's a fair bit of Amy bashing going on on UK TV chatsites at the moment, which is beginning to get on my nerves. One poster referred to her as 'immodest' after her reaction to a particularly brilliant solution she thought up in this episode, which nearly made my head explode. Would anyone have referred to a male character as 'immodest'?
posted by Lisa (Mon Apr 26 10, 4:22AM)
^ I'd been quite pleased with myself too!
posted by Jo the Hat (Mon Apr 26 10, 7:19AM)
@Lisa
Look on the bright side - those of us watching on BBC1 had all the tension punctured by a stupid, bright orange ident for the next programme popping up right on top of the Doctor as he made that great speech about traps.
I adore the BBC, but sometimes it really shoots itself in the foot. There has been something of a hoo-hah about this...
posted by Lisa (Mon Apr 26 10, 7:46AM)
^ yeah I couldn't figure that one out myself - was I too engrossed in the episode to notice? But they only showed it in England. Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland were cartoon Graham Norton free.
I'm not sure if it's Karen bashing or Amy bashing. I find that it's too early to tell if she's a good actress.
posted by Isobel (Mon Apr 26 10, 11:17AM)
Heh - my Sky+ went phooey and didn't record it, so I ended up watching it on the BBC iPlayer, and no silly orange thing.
Actually, those banner things are what I find incredibly irritating if I'm watching American TV and it's really really not something we should be copying!
Lisa, I've not seen so much Karen bashing - it's mostly people whining about Amy being cocky and how very dare she talk to Churchill like that. . .etc. I think the accusation running underneath is that the character is somehow 'unfeminine', which is what is winding me up.
posted by Jo the Hat (Mon Apr 26 10, 12:24PM)
@lisa and isobel
Yes, because god forbid that a girl should question the way men run the world! I've always (well, since he's turned up on Confidential discussing the scripts) had a teensy crush on Stephen Moffat, but am in danger of it becoming a proper infatuation if he keeps this up.
Amy's a great companion and a fabulous role model - I can only hope my Who-loving daughter (5) grows up like her!
posted by Max (Mon Apr 26 10, 6:53PM)
The 2nd time I watched, I was wondering why we had the opening scene with the dazed man in the field. He was drugged and had River's lipstick on his face. That reminded me of when John Hart kissed Gwen! Is River a time agent?
posted by Kenny (Mon Apr 26 10, 11:00PM)
Arrggg.. where's the bloggery? :(
posted by MaryAnn (Mon Apr 26 10, 11:25PM)
Coming momentarily...
posted by Lisa (Tue Apr 27 10, 4:22AM)
@Max I think he was some type of a security guard I thought it was quite surreal cos I was thinking that looks like The Streets! and it was him !weird! it looked like one of his videos too.
See I think Amy's a great companion but I don't know if Karen can act yet. I know Matt can act because I have seen him in other things. I'm not 100% sold on him or her. I have seen blogs, forums, etc, which criticise her acting style i.e. pouting and then the wide eyed stare.