Oceans (review)
It’s tough to give a yellow light to this one, because if you really want to see it, you should see it on the biggest screen you can find: the spectacular photography is the best thing about it. But the overall affect is most like that of a screensaver... and a short one, at that (I’ve seen “official” runtimes of between 86 and 89 minutes, but by my watch, it was more like 70 minutes). It’s pretty to look at, but the narrative -- by, in the English-language version, a bored-sounding Pierce Brosnan (Remember Me) -- is strained, at best. Filmmakers Jacques Perrin and Jacques Cluzaud (Winged Migration) journeyed the globe to capture images of undersea life, and they did a beautiful job of that: from the battle between a giant shrimp and a crab to crab armies on the march to jellyfish that look like cartoons Jules Verne would have imagined to sea lions lolling on a pristine beach, here is life in the oceans and at their fringe in ways we haven’t seen it before. And I love how the fact that almost no bodies of water are actually named -- you will not hear “Atlantic Ocean,” “Pacific waters,” or anything like that -- creates the (appropriate) evocation of just one world ocean on Planet Earth. That said, the movie fails to follow through on its opening gambit: “In the space of one lifetime as the human race reached for the stars, it seemed as if all of nature got out of whack.” A few brief images of pollution spewing from rivers and a sea lion swimming in brown, garbage-strewn water don’t do much to reinforce what I suspect the filmmakers are trying to say, that this is our last chance to see -- and save -- a threatened realm. If they wanted to present a simply sunny portrait of the oceans deep, fine. But then why broach the unpleasant side of the matter at all? share
Disqus commentsblog comments powered by Disqus |
posted:
Tue Apr 27 10, 4:26PM join the conversation: 3 pre-Disqus comments Disqus comments posted in: reviews > 2010 theatrical releases by MaryAnn Johanson infoMPAA: rated G viewed at a public multiplex screening official site IMDb trailer more reviews at: Movie Review Query Engine dvdAmazon US Amazon Canada read moredocumentary family/kids related· April 23: DVD alternatives to this weekend’s multiplex offerings · trailer break: ‘Oceans’ · African Cats (review) · North American box office: ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ back at No. 1 · question of the day: What movie are you most looking forward to in April? · question of the day: Are classic pulp novels too dated to make faithful transfers to the big screen? · John Carter (review) · Journey 2: The Mysterious Island (review) · question of the day: What is the appeal of steampunk? · watch it: Abney Park, “Airship Pirate” (steampunk music video) bloggyprevious post: many changes going on here... next post: watch it: “octopus steals my video camera and swims off with it (while it's Recording)” |











pre-Disqus comments
posted by ushtate (Tue May 04 10, 2:07PM)
Wonderful review; nailed it perfectly. My notions and thoughts exactly .... if there was any writing talent sitting at this laptop.
posted by Boingo (Wed May 05 10, 3:07PM)
Well that does it. I contemplated seeing it with my
one free ticket. Now, I'll wait for "Iron Man 2."
posted by AJP (Thu May 06 10, 3:23PM)
We went to see it. It is beautifully shot, but the narration is awful. Both the writing is bad, and the delivery is bad. Pierce Brosnan should not do voice-over work.