question of the day: Now it’s ‘Killer’s and ‘Knight and Day’: Why do movies seem to come in thematic pairs so often?Reader Feh in comments following my review of Killers asks: MaryAnn, do you have any insight into the ripoff pattern? Why do Hollywood movies tend to come out in pairs? Killers/Knight & Day, Abyss/Leviathan, Deep Impact/Armageddon. Feh then links to a story titled “11 Identical Movies Released at the Same Time” -- which dates back to last year, when we had Observe and Report and Paul Blart: Mall Cop back to back. The piece also mentions other recent apparent ripoffs including the pair of The Prestige and The Illusionist. And now we have Killers and, opening tomorrow, Knight and Day. (Reviews are supposed to be embargoed till tomorrow, but even though lots of critics have already posted theirs, I’ll honor the embargo and post mine at 12:01am tonight.) I say “apparent ripoffs” because I actually don’t think there’s anything nefarious going on. I doubt the studios are spying on one another and stealing ideas from their competition -- it’s probably not even necessary, when news about who has acquired what script from whom and which talent is attached to which project fills Variety and The Hollywood Reporter. I do think, however, that all the apparent copycatting is a symptom of how insular Hollywood is. The powerful folks at the studios all move in the same small circles, know the same people, go to the same parties, read the same newspapers and magazines. All it takes is one little mention of, say, Harry Houdini in some forum that all these people have access to, and it’s easy to see how that could spark off multiple movies about magicians. It doesn’t require that anyone steal anything from anybody, for there could have been scripts for magician stories that were written half a planet and half a decade apart languishing in development hell until suddenly a lightbulb goes off in a studio exec’s head. It’s not a coincidence that another exec gets the same lightbulb at the same time, but it’s nothing disreputable either. Of course, that’s just my theory. Maybe Hollywood really is playing an ongoing game of spy-versus-spy. What do you think: Why do movies seem to come in thematic pairs so often? (If you have a suggestion for a QOTD, feel free to email me. Responses to this QOTD sent by email will be ignored; please post your responses here.) support
Disqus commentsblog comments powered by Disqus |
posted:
Tue Jun 22 10, 11:01AM categories: talk amongst yourselves permalink 5 pre-Disqus comments Disqus comments tip jarshare
read more
embargoes
Harry Houdini Hollywood Reporter Illusionist Killers Knight and Day Observe and Report Paul Blart Mall Cop Prestige qotd Variety related· question of the day: What filmmaker has never made a bad movie? · question of the day: What non-hit of the 00s will be an acclaimed favorite by 2020? · question of the day: Which historical figures should we plunder as action heroes (and who should play them)? · Colin Firth and Natalie Portman are Oscar shoo-ins; everything else up for grabs: Oscar predictions · trailer break: ‘The Illusionist’ · Alliance of Women Film Journalists 2010 EDA Awards nominees · Online Film Critics Society 2010 Award nominees · DVDs to give: ‘Criss Angel Mindfreak: Collectors Edition’ · ‘Warehouse 13’ debuts on Sci Fi, er, SyFy tonight · Fairy Tale: A True Story (review) bloggyprevious post: omg: Josh Brolin did not say that about ‘Jonah Hex’... did he? next post: trailer break: ‘Winter’s Bone’ |
|
|
search
follow
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
(in case of site outages or other emergencies, I'll update my status on Twitter and Facebook)
|
||
follow FlickFilosopher.com no matter where you are online
|
||
share and enjoy
shop to support
support FlickFilosopher.com when you click through here and buy almost anything at:
• Amazon U.S.
• Amazon Canada
• Amazon U.K.
• Amazon Germany
• Amazon France
• Amazon Spain
• Amazon Italy
• Chapters/Indigo (Canada)
• Amazon U.S.
• Amazon Canada
• Amazon U.K.
• Amazon Germany
• Amazon France
• Amazon Spain
• Amazon Italy
• Chapters/Indigo (Canada)
pre-Disqus comments
posted by Sarah (Tue Jun 22 10, 11:44AM)
Well, movies spend a long time developing and being made, and after they're made they spend a long time on shelves. Maybe it's not so much tandem creation as tandem release; one studio says it's putting out its married spy caper, and the other is like, oh shit, we need to get ours out this summer or we'll look like idiots, take it off the shelf, boys.
None of that, however, explains Repo Men and Repo. Two disaster movies I understand. Two movies about futuristic organ harvesting?
posted by Left_Wing_Fox (Tue Jun 22 10, 11:36PM)
Yeah, Antz/A Bug's life wasn't the only similarity between PDI/Dreamworks and Pixar/Disney.
1998: Insects! Antz vs. A Bug's Life.
2000: South America! Road to El Dorado and Emperor's New Groove.
2001: Monsters! Monsters Inc vs. Shrek.
2003/2004: Fish! Shark Tale vs. Finding Nemo.
Eventually the zoo escape of Madagascar and the Wild as well.
It was weird. None of the films are actually all that similar, aside from being animated, and having the same general setting. Dreamworks also relies more heavily on celebrity caricature with their voice actors than Pixar.
Still, it was very weird.
posted by Bill (Wed Jun 23 10, 12:05AM)
I am just thinking out of my ass here, but if I had to guess, I would say that the blockbuster industry is pretty data driven. they focus-group-test-screen-whatever the hell out of movies (don't they?). anyway, if the numbers folks are worth a damn, i can see how two studios, through analysis of reactions to batches of dissimilar films in 2008, might arrive at the same conclusions, i.e., we gotta have a magic movie or an armageddon movie ready for 2010.
posted by JoshDM (Wed Jun 23 10, 1:04AM)
I've noticed this for years, but I can't recall which one was the opposite pair for Twister. I remember there being one, but I've forgotten it.
posted by JoshDM (Wed Jun 23 10, 1:11AM)
As a kid, I never could understand why Deep Star Six, Leviathan and The Abyss came out at the same time; the Volcano and Dante's Peak dupes came out around the same time as Armageddon/Deep Impact, IIRC, so that was also quite high-profile noticeable.