question of the day: How many things can you find wrong with the cover of Vanity Fair’s Hollywood issue?
Vanity Fair’s annual Hollywood issue is out, with the its traditional cover featuring young talent on the rise. The selection of actors and the way they’re photographed always comes under massive scrutiny and complaint, and the ritual is in full swing this year. First, here’s the cover:
(Click here for a full size version.) The thing that strikes me most is what Crushable points out, that the actresses are “virtually unrecognizable”: [T]he makeup artist went way overboard on the smoky eyes and red lips. The eleven young actresses all look beautiful, but they also look interchangeable. Really, it’s impossible to identify more than one or two of them without scrutinizing it really closely. This would just seem to highlight the fact that has underscored the notion of “the Hollywood starlet” from the beginnings of Hollywood: actresses should be mostly interchangeable. There’s certainly no point in standing out and being different when the roles available to women are mostly as furniture anyway. Crushable’s cheat sheet on who’s who: I’m gonna tell you who’s in each panel, and I bet it’ll surprise you. Left panel: Rooney Mara, Jennifer Lawrence, Mia Wasikowska, and Jessica Chastain—these ladies are all mostly recognizable since two are Oscar-nominated, but I was sure that Mia was actually Amber Heard. Chicology notes that the cover is “very white, very thin”: Do you think Vanity Fair purposefully left out Octavia Spencer (or better yet, Melissa McCarthy) due to her weight? The Improper runs down a list of names that might have been included in the shoot: [I]f being a breakout star is a criteria what about Emily Browning, 23, who starred in the mesmerizing movie “Sleeping Beauty.” Also a surprise miss is Emma Roberts, 20, who was crazy good in “The Art of Getting By,” and “Scream 4.” Jezebel can’t help but notice that black actresses have been pushed aside once again: Pariah's Adepero Oduye and Mission Impossible's Paula Patton are the only two ladies of color, and they are not on the power panel, but on the right two-thirds of the cover, which is folded up and tucked away when on newsstands. (And click over to Jezebel to see years’ worth of examples.) How many things can you find wrong with the cover of Vanity Fair’s Hollywood issue? Which nonwhite or nonthin actresses would you have included in the mix? Do you like the anonymizing makeup? What else strikes you as not quite right about the cover? (If you have a suggestion for a QOTD, feel free to email me. Responses to this QOTD sent by email will be ignored; please post your responses here.) Disqus commentsblog comments powered by Disqus |
posted:
Fri Feb 03 12, 10:15AM categories: talent buzz talk amongst yourselves permalink Disqus comments tip jarshare
read more
Abigail Breslin
Adepero Oduye Amanda Seyfried Amber Heard Art of Getting By Ashley Greene Brit Marling Castle Chicology Chloe Moretz Cowboys and Aliens Crushable Descendants Elizabeth Olsen Elle Fanning Ellen Page Emily Browning Emma Roberts Emma Watson Felicity Jones Hailee Steinfeld Harry Potter Hollywood hates women Inception Jennifer Lawrence Jessica Chastain Jezebel Lily Collins Melissa McCarthy Mia Wasikowska Mission Impossible Ghost Protocol Octavia Spencer Olivia Wilde Oscars Pariah Paula Patton qotd Rooney Mara Scream 4 Secret Life of the American Teenager Shailene Woodley Sleeping Beauty Stana Katic Twilight Vanity Fair related· Pariah (review) · The Descendants (review) · Nathan Fillion’s got a new show? · Cowboys & Aliens (review) · Another Earth (review) · The Artist will have a good night (and other Oscar predictions) · AWFJ announces 2011 awards · question of the day: What was the most sexist movie or movie moment in 2011? · Alliance of Women Film Journalists 2010 EDA Awards nominees · The Art of Getting By (review) bloggyprevious post: London photo of the day: St Paul’s at night next post: The Hunger Games (the final? trailer) |









