Today’s question comes from Stingraylady, who writes:
I recently took my daughter to see Daniel Radcliff in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying on Broadway. He was fabulous – gave 110% and made it a really special experience for his fans. The show, however, was mediocre at best. The characters were clichés, the plot obvious, and the music forgettable. This got me thinking about movies and shows that make it completely on casting. Gladiator comes to mind. The script was ridiculous, and even the concept of a gladiator movie was absurd at the time. But I went anyway once I saw Russell Crowe in the trailer. The performances made the movie an engaging experience; snark didn’t enter in until further recollection and later viewings showed obvious plot holes and far-fetched twists. Anyway, there’s probably plenty more, and I’d be curious what others had to say.
I disagree about Gladiator: I think it works on many levels beyond Russell Crowe’s magnificent performance. But Stingraylady’s point is taken. So:
What movies succeed entirely on the basis of casting and performances alone?
Since Stingraylady’s question from prompted by a stage performance, feel free to include theater if you want. TV, too… though I suspect that as a longer form of storytelling, TV can’t ever cut it on actors alone.
(If you have a suggestion for a QOTD, feel free to email me. Responses to this QOTD sent by email will be ignored; please post your responses here.)