more by MaryAnn

Hollywood’s loyal opposition | by maryann johanson

Machine Gun Preacher (review)

2 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Google+ 2 StumbleUpon 0 Email -- 2 Flares ×

Gerard Butler in Machine Gun Preacher

Yes, it’s yet another story about white people helping poor black folk, but as tales of imperialistic cultural colonialism as spiritual growth go, this one is solid stuff, equally horrific in depicting the real-life evils it is fighting as it is uplifting and soothing of the viewer’s own guilty soul. (Not that one feel-good movie should absolve us of ignoring the bad stuff happening in the world, but sometimes it’s a relief to know that someone is doing something about it, no?) The real-life evils aren’t limited to brutal African civil wars, either. This docudrama doesn’t sugarcoat what an awful person Sam Childers (Gerard Butler: How to Train Your Dragon) is as his based-in-fact story opens: a violent junkie, he emotionally abuses his wife, Lynn (Michelle Monaghan: Source Code) and ignores his toddler daughter (played later as a teen by Madeline Carroll: Flipped). But a few of his own really terrible crimes finally shake him up, and a reluctant trip to his wife’s Pentecostal church quickly turns Jesus into his new addiction. But not — and here is my favorite thing about this movie — in an obnoxious way. Screenwriter Jason Keller and director Marc Forster (Quantum of Solace) have made a film about religious faith without presuming the viewer shares it, and as someone who doesn’t share that faith, I appreciate the lack of sanctimony. I also love that this is a story about a man who does something useful and positive with his faith (unlike the vast majority of public religious figures, who appear to believe that God wants them to be misogynist and homophobic panty-sniffers). For Sam, inspired by a visiting preacher, heads to Uganda and the Sudan to build orphanages for and kick some ass on behalf of orphans of the civil war, including child soldiers. Now, it’s true that the warzone-action stuff — which is intense — sits somewhat oddly next to the huggy-feely stuff. But that’s sorta what you have to expect from a movie called Machine Gun Preacher. Butler is hugely engaging as a tough guy surprised to find he cares, and there’s a fantastic supporting performance by the always great Michael Shannon (Jonah Hex) as Sam’s junkie pal. But most importantly, the film’s heart and its boot are both in the right place, and it doesn’t pretend to have any easy answers, just a hard row that must be hoed. Jesus would approve, I suspect.

US/Canada release date: Sep 23 2011 | UK release date: Nov 2 2011

Flick Filosopher Real Rating: rated RMC for really muscular Christianity
MPAA: rated R for violent content including disturbing images, language, some drug use and a scene of sexuality
BBFC: rated 15 (contains strong language, violence, threat and gory injury detail)

viewed at a public multiplex screening

official site | IMDb | trailer
more reviews: Movie Review Query Engine
  • Tbonehampton

    “Yes, it’s yet another story about white people helping poor black folk, but as tales of imperialistic cultural colonialism…”

    Where did you go to college?  Oh yeah, they all teach this, and it’s true, but it is getting old and as usual only represents one perspective-facet of a much larger picture.  From a positive spin–some one has got to help who has the resources, time, energy, know-how, will and skills, and it just so happens that many times that person is “white”  oh the dreaded word.  In short, if folks can’t help themselves some one needs to step up. 

  • RogerBW

    It’s also a cliched and lazy storytelling device. Your argument would make sense in a world that didn’t already have hundreds, thousands of films telling the same basic story: What These Folks Need Is A White Man.

  • Cmingle2

    Your a very good writer; You’re very easy to read and the flow of your writing is noteworthy.  But your rediculous open statement about “another white, Christian movie helping those black people in Africa is simply appalling.  Why don’t you just review the movie in an objective way–which you did after your opening sentence–which would be being honest in your profession as a reviewer.  

  • CapitalistInfidel

    What do you expect from a radical far left nut job?

  • Andre Dufour

    It’s actually ambiguously based on a true story regarding Sam Childers and his effort to save the lives of quite literally hundreds of children in the Sudan from the LRA. There is absolutely no relevance to him being white and your judgement of his character played by Butler and more importantly the man himself due to his race and past mistakes starkly points to you as the bigot in these idiotic observations of yours. You’re a poor critic and a pitiful human being. Put your keyboard away while you’re still ahead.

2 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Google+ 2 StumbleUpon 0 Email -- 2 Flares ×