Predators (review)

Get new reviews in your email in-box or in an app by becoming a paid Substack subscriber or Patreon patron.

Prey and Prejudice

“I woke up in freefall,” Adrien Brody gripes as Predators opens. He’s not lying: Our introduction to this world comes as his does, when he opens his eyes to find himself plummeting from space toward the surface of an alien planet, the parachute on his back not yet open, with no certain indication that it will open. (It does, of course, or else he wouldn’t be around to complain later about this appalling treatment.)

It’s sort of an astonishing moment, not quite like anything we’ve seen before onscreen, and for just that moment, I had hope: Was, perhaps, Hungarian-American filmmaker Nimród Antal about to give us a film to match the verve and audacity of his 2003 debut, Kontroll, which is — no kidding — an action movie about gangs of ticket takers on the Budapest subway? Alas, it was not to be: Almost immediately after Brody’s landing planetside, Predators sets itself up as a Xerox copy of the 1987 original, Predator, in which the Arnold Schwarzenegger-led team of Special Forces badasses get picked off one by one by a visiting alien badass warrior in the jungles of Guatemala. It’s competently executed, but someone forgot to ask what the point of the whole endeavor was, beyond, perhaps establishing Adrien Brody’s action creds, in case that Oscar for The Pianist starts holding him back from getting good work.
Here, the human badasses — there’s a bunch more of them who’ve been tossed from orbit along with Brody (Splice, Fantastic Mr. Fox) — have been imported by the badass alien warriors onto a sort of planetwide game preserve, so the badass alien warriors can hunt them for sport, but it’s pretty much the same movie we saw back in 1987. It’s much better than the more recent Alien vs. Predator, but that wasn’t hard to do; it’s not much better than a cheesy Syfy Original film: the cast is more appealing, for the most part, and the director is more talented, but Predators has just as little to say as whatever made-for-cable crap will turn up on TV this weekend. There is a modicum of mystery surrounding Brody’s character, who refuses to reveal his name or what kind of badass he is. Is he a soldier? A criminal? There is a modicum of mystery to be had in wondering which of the humans will die first: Will it be the death-row convict (Walton Goggins: Miracle at St. Anna, The World’s Fastest Indian)? Will it be the drug cartel enforcer (Danny Trejo: Battle for Terra, Planet Terror)? Will it be the Russian army guy (Oleg Taktarov: Righteous Kill, Miami Vice)? Will it be the Yakuza (Louis Ozawa Changchien)? Will it be the practicioner of African war atrocities (Mahershalalhashbaz Ali: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)? Will it be the meek doctor (Topher Grace: Valentine’s Day, Spider-Man 3) who seems to have gotten caught up in the game by mistake? Surely it won’t be the badass chick (Alice Braga: Repo Man, Blindness), because then the movie would be all out of chicks…

Problem is, we don’t much care about any of these people. The movie mostly doesn’t even bother to expand on their general awfulness as human beings, just lets their jobs speak for them. The only one newbie screenwriters Alex Litvak and Michael Finch deign to give the slightest bit of, you know, character to is the convict, and then only by having him spout a “joke” about how many “bitches” he’s going to “rape” when he gets home, which is just… ewww.

Mostly, it’s like a big episode of The Twilight Zone — humans are the prey! — with lots of gunplay and lots of DayGlo gore. (The aliens bleed neon green. It’s actually even less interesting than that.) We don’t even get a mini nuke like we did at the end of Predator. *yawn*

share and enjoy
If you’re tempted to post a comment that resembles anything on the film review comment bingo card, please reconsider.
If you haven’t commented here before, your first comment will be held for MaryAnn’s approval. This is an anti-spam, anti-troll, anti-abuse measure. If your comment is not spam, trollish, or abusive, it will be approved, and all your future comments will post immediately. (Further comments may still be deleted if spammy, trollish, or abusive, and continued such behavior will get your account deleted and banned.)
notify of
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
view all comments
Fri, Jul 09, 2010 6:20am

Well that’s a bummer. Of course, I speak as someone who actually liked AvP…still, I was hopefull that this would kick but.

Fri, Jul 09, 2010 10:22am

Senator Lawrence Fishburne of Louisiana.

Fri, Jul 09, 2010 7:29pm

Can’t say I liked AvP at all. I liked AvP:Requiem quite a bit, since it made good on the “Aliens vs Predator” part — you know, the part that gives the movie a reason to exist — pretty much from the get-go, while also having human characters I almost gave two shits about. It also had some new ideas, like new gadgets for the predator and new types of alien. It’s still not as good as the franchises it’s combining, but still pretty good imo.

Predators wasn’t something I had high hopes for, I pretty much just hoped it would make good on the promise of the title, and give us a movie that is to Predator what Aliens was to Alien (minus the high expectations).

Instead it sounds like it is to Predator what every cheesy monster-in-space thriller Alien-ripoff was to Alien if they hadn’t had copyright and trademark issues. :P


Thu, Apr 11, 2013 12:47am

The title “Predators” refers to the whole lot of them (the Predators and the belligerent humans they are hunting) being “predators.” How much Antal is riffing on the “Aliens” title seems purely speculation.

BTW, MaryAnn, you have Alice Braga linked to the wrong movie here. She was in the 2010 Repo Men, not the 1984 Repo Man (she wasn’t even one-year-old when Repo Man came out).