Geostorm movie review: weather bomb

Get new reviews in your email in-box or in an app by becoming a paid Substack subscriber or Patreon patron.

Geostorm red light

MaryAnn’s quick take…

Almost hilariously terrible: absurd plot machinations, dubious politics, not a single character to care about. And it doesn’t even give good disaster porn.tweet
I’m “biast” (pro): big science fiction fan
I’m “biast” (con): not a fan of what Hollywood often does with sci fi
(what is this about? see my critic’s minifesto)

Who was it who said, “Everybody talks about the weather, but no one does anything about it”?tweet Well, we showed that guy! After the catastrophic weather year of 2019 (which apparently made 2017 look like a pleasantly warm and breezy day), we — that is, humanity — “fought back” against, I guess, ourselves and the climate disasters we brought upon our planet, by launching a network of weather-control satellites covering the entire globe, and operated from a newly supercool International Space Station, which has a big wheel and gravity and factories to make more satellites, and which houses the 600 scientists who make it all go.

We can’t even get back to the moon but the ISS will look like this in the 2020s? Ha.
We can’t even get back to the moon but the ISS will look like this in the 2020s? Ha.tweet

According to Geostorm, the best way to make this indubitably impossible feat happen in only three years is to put Gerard Butler (London Has Fallen, Gods of Egypt) in charge. Because, sure, he’s totally plausible as the guy who is simultaneously capable of 1) designing the entire system, 2) leading an international multidisciplinary team of scientists and engineers to build and run the thing, and 3) being a lone-wolf hotshot who won’t take orders and resorts to violence to get his way. (CV: “Rogue badass and project leader.”tweet) Oh, but never mind! Now he’s off the project, after the politicians in charge decide that punching some dude in the face is neither good safety protocol nor conducive to international cooperation.

No, but wait, he’s back again! Because a few years later, something is going horrible wrong with “Dutchboy,” as everyone calls the system: instead of making the weather nice, it’s making the weather deadly. And who else is going to be able to fix the damn thing but the unconventional genius they probably should never have fired? Or might it be that there is some sort of secret scheme of sabotage and political maneuvering going on just as the United States is about to hand over management of Dutchboy to the UN? (Wait: Dutchboy was built by the whole world but America has been controlling it? How did that happen?) Might someone in Washington DC or on the ISS see some diplomatic benefit to “accidentally” icing a desert village in Afghanistan or superheating gas mains Hong Kong until they blow up half the city?

Dean Devlin saw Gravity and thought: We can make it dumber...
Dean Devlin saw Gravity and thought: “We can make it dumber…”tweet

No spoilers, but if this were the cheapo made-for-Syfy junk it should have been, it might have been titled Conspiranado.tweet Instead, this is mega-budget high-profile studio junk that somehow attracted a cast of luminaries including Andy Garcia (Passengers, Ghostbusters) (as the President of the United States), Ed Harris (mother!, Run All Night) (as the US Secretary of State), and — in one-scene cameos that would be criminal if the movie weren’t so dreadful, but I understand why they’d want to minimize their appearances here — Richard Schiff (playing a sort of evil version of his beloved West Wing character Toby Ziegler) and Mare Winningham (Philomena, Mirror Mirror), with just one line of dialogue, and a throwaway at that. The presence of other younger talents is equally mysterious: Abbie Cornish (RoboCop, Seven Psychopaths) as a Secret Service agent often cannot hide her incredulity at the things her character is required to say; Jim Sturgess (Cloud Atlas, One Day) as a DC honcho and Butler’s brother seems to have resolved to simply smirk his way through his every scene, including the ones in which it is entirely inappropriate, like when discussing the possible destruction by extreme weather of major cities.

General Motors’ Geo Storm, produced from 1990 to 1993. Also a disaster.
General Motors’ Geo Storm, produced from 1990 to 1993. Also a disaster.tweet

Tsunamis in Dubai, hailstorms in Tokyo, lightning in Orlando. Geostorm doesn’t even give good disaster porn: it’s CGI cartoonish and mostly doesn’t involve characters we care about. One catastrophe, in Rio de Janeiro, hopes we’ll be invested in whether an anonymous lady in a bikini will survive, though probably she was just an excuse to get some PG-rated near nudity onscreen, because we don’t actually learn whether she makes it out alive. (Another calamity in India imperils a small dog — and also tens of thousands of humans, but mostly one small dog — and we are eventually assured of the small dog’s safety. So we know where Geostorm’s priorities lie.)

Perhaps the movie’s cleverest trick is that it never makes us care about any of the characters. It tries, it really does. But with the entirety of human civilization at stake, it’s difficult to care whether Butler’s and Sturgess’s estranged brothers will reconcile by the end of the movie. Butler’s teenaged daughter (Talitha Bateman: Annabelle: Creation, The 5th Wave) seems pretty cool, but she’s literally nothing more than a tacky talisman to humanize him: “Millions of people are gonna die,” he grumbles at one point, “and one of them is my daughter.” Thank god he has fathered some offspring, or the planet would be doomed.

Ah, I see you have the subroutine that goes ping...
“Ah, I see you have the subroutine that goes ping…”tweet

And yet I have only scratched the surface of how almost hilariously terrible Geostorm is. This is a movie in which complex systems like Dutchboy’s can be magically manipulated, but only according to the needs of the plot (such as it is): computers will erase some vital bits of information but not others; some procedures must be performed manually, if it means that will maximize the danger to the hero. Mystery-solving minor characters leap from “I think something is going on” to “I’ve figured it all out!” in the space of a single cut, yet this does not save us from watching many people sitting at computers all over the world and up in orbit staring at code that has been production-designed in an attempt to make it intriguing. Butler’s and Sturgess’s brothers use an absurd sibling-code from their childhood to talk over a transmission that is being eavesdropped upon, a code so complex that is would be almost impossible to use on the fly, without a lot of preparation… and then the next time they talk via the same method, they speak openly, without any indication that the eavesdropping issue has been solved. The revelation of the villain — who must be supersmart in order to have pulled off what is happening here — revolves around the ol’ mentioning a name that s/he wouldn’t know if s/he weren’t evil. Because one ticking countdown to doom isn’t enough, we get two,tweet including the one till “Geostorm,” the cascading weather disasters set off by the Dutchboy satellites that will utterly wreck the planet… which must have been thoughtfully programmed by the conspirators for the benefit of those trying to stop it, because it certainly wouldn’t have been part of Dutchboy’s original programming.

There is a special kind of stupid to Geostorm that almost makes one suspect that it’s deliberate.tweet Why would Dean Devlin, the writer and producer of Stargate and Independence Day making his feature directorial debut, want to make humanity’s attempts to fix global warming look so ridiculous, so idiotic, so inherently prone to subversion that we would be fools to contemplate embarking upon such an endeavor? Does he know something we don’t know? Was he hinting at something with his previous work? Has he already sold us out to the aliens? I mean, if we are weakened and distracted as a species by hurricane after heatwave, we’re not gonna be able to put up much of a fight when ET comes for our water and/or to make us their slaves. I’m just sayin’…



share and enjoy
             
If you’re tempted to post a comment that resembles anything on the film review comment bingo card, please reconsider.
If you haven’t commented here before, your first comment will be held for MaryAnn’s approval. This is an anti-spam, anti-troll measure. If you’re not a spammer or a troll, your comment will be approved, and all your future comments will post immediately.
subscribe
notify of
23 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
view all comments
Danielm80
Danielm80
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 11:22am

There’s something wrong with Hollywood when no one can find an interesting role for Jim Sturgess, Abbie Cornish, or Richard Schiff.

IntrepidNormal
IntrepidNormal
reply to  Danielm80
Thu, Oct 26, 2017 6:00pm

Jim Sturgess isn’t that good of an actor. He would have disappeared a long time ago if he weren’t good-looking and white.

MaryAnn Johanson
reply to  IntrepidNormal
Thu, Nov 02, 2017 12:19pm

He’s not *that* good-looking. Compared to mere mortals? Sure. Compared to the supernaturally gorgeous people that Hollywood finds and promotes? No.

IntrepidNormal
IntrepidNormal
reply to  MaryAnn Johanson
Fri, Nov 03, 2017 8:53pm

True enough.

David_Conner
David_Conner
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 11:43am

What’s with all the rampant anti-Netherlands prejudice in Hollywood these days?

MaryAnn Johanson
reply to  David_Conner
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 5:43pm

To be fair to the movie, I don’t think there’s anything anti-Netherlands in nicknaming the satellite net after a Dutch legend. The opposite, if anything.

Atomic Fireball
Atomic Fireball
reply to  David_Conner
Wed, Oct 25, 2017 1:29am

These dyke-plugging, wooden-shoe wearing, chocolate-and-cheese slobbering subhumans need to be put in their place. Go ride a windmill traitor.

RogerBW
RogerBW
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 11:45am

“Hilariously terrible” I can live with. Once it’s very very cheap to watch, anyway. Theatrical release for this seems like a sign of desperation (not to mention “I can do Emmerich as well as Emmerich can”).

MaryAnn Johanson
reply to  RogerBW
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 5:43pm

Wait till it’s on Netflix or Prime. Don’t pay for it. Don’t encourage them…

MPC
MPC
reply to  MaryAnn Johanson
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 9:06pm

I think “Geostorm” would be right at home on Syfy… it doesn’t even deserve to be on a high-end streaming service like Netflix.

Dr. Rocketscience
Dr. Rocketscience
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 5:01pm

You know you’re in trouble when Butler isn’t playing a caricature of a Scot, and yet doesn’t bother to even try to moderate his Scottish accent.

MaryAnn Johanson
reply to  Dr. Rocketscience
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 5:44pm

He does, though. His accent here isn’t like his own normal voice.

Completely randomly, Butler’s character does note at one point that he and his brother were born in the UK. (Sturgess is also English. His American accent is fine.)

Dr. Rocketscience
Dr. Rocketscience
reply to  MaryAnn Johanson
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 5:47pm

Really? That’s not what I got from the trailer.

David_Conner
David_Conner
reply to  MaryAnn Johanson
Wed, Oct 25, 2017 9:39pm

In the proud tradition of Michael Caine in The Swarm!

bronxbee
bronxbee
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 5:16pm

i do have to say that the name “Dutch Boy” for the weather program tickled me a bit. but like i said, even the trailer was hilariously awful.

Beowulf
Beowulf
reply to  bronxbee
Tue, Oct 24, 2017 6:53pm

Well, geez, isn’t that to recall the tale of the little dutch boy with his finger in the dike? (Watch it!) Is it true that this film was made some time ago and underwent some (apparently unsuccessful) reshoots? The wolf, man.

amanohyo
amanohyo
reply to  Beowulf
Wed, Oct 25, 2017 1:07pm

Yes, for some reason Warner Bros. let Devlin, a once profitable producer of lowbrow action flicks who hasn’t had a hit since the 90’s, get behind the camera, and he triumphantly returned over a year ago with what was rumored to be an unwatchable mess. A team of editors has been trying to cut this thing into a vaguely entertaining shape for a long, long time. Still not as bad as The Snowman, which was so rushed that large chunks of the final script weren’t even filmed. What are the qualifications for being a big producer at a major studio again? Lots of money, powerful friends, a track record of success and/or a penis, and a monstrous ego? Eesh WB, you did well (financially at least) with IT, Dunkirk, and Wonder Woman, get your shit together! I don’t want to live in a world dominated by the Disney Cinematic Universe.

MaryAnn Johanson
reply to  amanohyo
Thu, Oct 26, 2017 12:38pm

a track record of success and/or a penis

Mostly just the latter.

PJK
PJK
Thu, Oct 26, 2017 2:31pm

The trailer made me suspect that this movie was a dumpster fire, so it good to see that confirmed.

I see on IMDB that Devlin has been doing some directing for TV (both series and movies), so there was no excuse for Warner Brothers not to check out his directing work before they hired him. Though it seems that he’s also the producer and one of the script writers on this thing, so I guess he hired himself for the job.

Maybe Warner Brothers thought that Ronald Emmerich would direct this? Not that that would have necessarily made for a better movie, but at least he seems capable of directing a big budget disaster movie, no matter how ridiculous the actual plot of the movie.

IntrepidNormal
IntrepidNormal
Thu, Oct 26, 2017 5:59pm

Always assume I care more about a dog in an imperiled crowd of extras than the actual people. I know nothing about those characters, but at least I know that the dog is a dog.

Anna
Anna
reply to  IntrepidNormal
Fri, Oct 27, 2017 6:38pm

I think the dog thing is a shout-out to a similar scene in Independence Day, where lots of people die but a dog is saved. After all the director of this was the writer and producer of Independence Day, as MaryAnn points out.

IntrepidNormal
IntrepidNormal
reply to  Anna
Fri, Nov 03, 2017 8:54pm

“The dog makes it” is a trope Roland Emmerich returns to in just about every movie, one of the few narrative choices of his I agree with.

Kielioss
Kielioss
Thu, Nov 15, 2018 6:05am

Excellent review! Should’ve been called Sh*tstorm.