your £$ support needed

part of a small rebellion | by maryann johanson

Jonah Hex (review)

Mostly Dead All Day

Jonah Hex ain’t immortal, he’ll tell ya for free as Jonah Hex opens — it’s just that he’s “cursed with knowing the other side” on accounta being half dead that one time, till Indian magic brought him some of the way back. Now he’s got a Pushing Daisies Ned the Pie Man sort of talent for talkin’ to deceased folk, just for a bit before they have to die again and stay dead.

If Hex (Josh Brolin: Milk, W.) can talk to the dead, then he’s probably the only one (apart from Ned the Pie Man) who could have any meaningful interaction with this movie. Mostly dead is a little alive, a miracle man once said, but that cannot be said about Jonah Hex, which doesn’t seem to know what its own self is all about: is it a comedy? a science fantasy? a supernatural revenge thriller? Throwing in spare nods at these genres like it’s whispering that it doesn’t know what it wants to be means it ends up being not much of anything at all — it’s certainly as lacking in spirit and intention as a corpse.

Hell, Jonah Hex ain’t even really the Western it seems — at first, on the surface — to be, since it appears to take place mostly in the old East(ern part of the United States). Though I still want to make a crack about “suicide bombers of the Old West” — imagine me drawling there — because “suicide bombers of muttonchopped Washington DC” doesn’t have quite the same punch, and because someone appeared to find the notion of bringing the scourge of the early 21st century back in the late 19th “daring” or perhaps “edgy”… and maybe it might have been, handled in the right way.

There’s no right way about anything here. Maybe it’s all the fault of the source graphic novel, but probably not, since it appears to bear little resemblance to what’s on screen. I suspect we can blame screenwriters Mark Neveldine and Brian Taylor (they of Crank fame) for completely failing to find anything actually relevant in Quentin Turnbull (John Malkovich: Burn After Reading, Changeling), Confederate officer turned “terroriste,” as the Mexicans call him; no really, that’s this flick’s idea of humor (at least I think that was intended to be funny). Turnbull and his plan to steal a steampunk weapon of mass destruction and kill lots of people on America’s big birthday — July 4, 1876 — utterly fails to work as would-be deranged comedy, nor as straight-up suspense drama, nor as anything truly uneasy-making. A 19th-century touchstone for modern political issues? Nah. Who wants icky pertinence in their summer action movies? But then why the “terroriste” bullshit?

Often bad movies feel like they’ve been chopped up, cut down from something that might — might — have been better, and that’s the case here. With a running time of, by my watch, 72 minutes — not the 84 or 87 I’ve seen around, not even when the padded-out end credits are added in — there’s plenty of space for a bit of character, a bit of color, a bit of anything to make this feel like a fully fleshed-out story instead of a disjointed jumble of barely connected setpieces. Faces appear and disappear and reappear again with no rhyme or reason, such as Will Arnett’s (When in Rome, G-Force) army officer, who gets to serve a mysterious double duty: The question of why he’s here at all is compounded by the conundrum of whether he’s supposed to be funny, merely because it’s Arnett. (He’s not funny, but neither is anything else that appears to be aiming at humor here.) Why did director Jimmy Hayward (Horton Hears a Who!) torture poor Megan Fox (Jennifer’s Body, Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen), transforming her via a squeezed-tight corset into something disturbingly freakish when she barely has cause to be here at all, except as a pawn that can be used against Hex? Who is the Charleston businessman (played by Wes Bentley: American Beauty) who wanders in and out of the action to talk to Turnbull about things we’ve heard nothing about? Why not give us even a little bit more of Hex’s story with the Indians, instead of leaving it all to look like the flick is simply obnoxiously appropriating a bit of Native culture for effect, for a dash of spiritual whatsit?

“The very fate of our nation may rest on Jonah Hex,” President Grant (Aidan Quinn: Nine Lives, Bobby Jones: Stroke of Genius) announces at some juncture that is, perhaps, meant to be vital. That’s probably the funniest line in the movie. Or the scariest. Either way, as long as the very fate of nothing rests on Jonah Hex, this is one disaster that will quickly be forgotten.

Please support truly independent film criticism
as generously as you can.
support my work at PayPal support my work at Patreon support my work at Ko-Fi support my work at Liberapay More details...

Jonah Hex (2010) | directed by Jimmy Hayward
US/Can release: Jun 18 2010
UK/Ire release: Sep 03 2010

MPAA: rated PG-13 rating for intense sequences of violence and action, disturbing images and sexual content
BBFC: rated 15 (contains frequent moderate violence, some strong)

viewed at a private screening with an audience of critics

official site | IMDb | trailer
more reviews: Movie Review Query Engine | Rotten Tomatoes

If you’re tempted to post a comment that resembles anything on the film review comment bingo card, please reconsider.

  • It sounds suspiciously like they threw away almost everything about the original Jonah Hex character save his name and his Southern origin and tried to turn his story into The Wild, Wild West II.

    And wouldn’t the 19th century equivalent of terrorist be anarchist? They threw bombs, too. Indeed, the traditional cartoon image of a lighted bomb (the round, bowling ball-like items that usually had a lighted fuse in one end) comes from the bombs that were once used by the more outlawish of anarchists. (Granted, law-abiding anarchist is kind of a contradiction in terms but still…)

  • JoshDM

    I had such high hopes for the character, as Jonah Hex is a fantastic concept, but they failed at bringing him to the screen.

    PRODUCER: “Jonah Hex, that’s a comic book character, right? Then GIVE HIM SUPER POWERS!”

  • dconner

    JoshDM, Yes, that’s exactly what I thought!

    I was mildly glad to see that they didn’t adapt the couple of overtly-supernatural horror-based Jonah Hex miniseries from the ’90s, but apparently they couldn’t just make a frickin’ Western.

  • dconner

    Oh, and comic book Jonah Hex does have a super power. Only one, but it’s quite sufficient: the power of being a Total Badass.

  • Barb

    At least they did him good in the Justice League animated series a few ago.

  • “Granted, law-abiding anarchist is kind of a contradiction in terms but still…”

    Based on the anarchists I’ve met, they can be anarchists and accidentally be a law-abiding citizen. They’re pacifists, and dislike capitalism ust as much as politics so often don’t make enough money to have to pay taxes. As long as someone is nice to people and flies under the radar, they can live without thinking about the law most of their lives.

    But I did meet one whose wife left him and took their daughter, but in order to contest custody he had to file an income statement, but he hadn’t paid taxes on 10 years of income, so found himself in delicate conversations with IRS through a lawyer.

  • deering

    “If Hex (Josh Brolin: Milk, W.) can talk to the dead, then he’s probably the only one (apart from Ned the Pie Man)..”

    …or Hellboy. :) That said, JH looks like a “who the devil asked for it?” cross between WILD WILD WEST and GHOST RIDER.

  • Joan

    Wow, 72 minutes? That’s a rather brisk change from the usual two-and-a-half-hours-plus behemoths that lousy comic book/action/horror/etc movies seem to end up as these days. Pity they aren’t 72 good minutes.

  • Russell

    This is why they need to start asking directors a very important question: “Yes, great, you’ve read the comic book… but WHICH comics did you read?”. Oh, if only they’d gone with the Jonah Hex from the original series who was so reminiscent of Clint Eastwood’s Man With No Name.

  • Bri

    For that matter, I wouldn’t mind a good supernatural Western either (no, there doesn’t need to be another zombie shoot-em-up, or the mindlessness of BloodRayne 2/or Dusk To Dawn 3 (I think it was 3)…

    Heck, sometimes I wonder what the RPG Deadlands might be like as a movie…and then I see something like Jonah Hex.

Pin It on Pinterest