Quantcast
become a Patreon patron

cultural vandal | by maryann johanson

Oscar Nominated Live Action Shorts 2019 (91st Academy Awards) review

Oscar Nominated Live Action Shorts 2019 green light Detainment

MaryAnn’s quick take…

My pick: Vincent Lambe’s controversial and profoundly harrowing “Detainment,” a dramatization of the real-life police interrogations of the 10-year-old boys who killed a toddler in England in 1993.tweet
I’m “biast” (pro): nothing
I’m “biast” (con): nothing
(what is this about? see my critic’s minifesto)

Children in jeopardy is the motif running through four of the five Oscar nominees for live-action short this year, which makes one wonder whether there isn’t a certain anxiety in the zeitgeist that caused the Academy to gravitate toward these films. And when one considers that the children under threat and stress are all boys, and men in Hollywood have come under particular pushback for their behavior in the past 18 months… well. (AMPAS membership is around 70 percent male.)

I suspect that Vincent Lambe’s controversial “Detainment” [IMDb|official site] will win. His dramatization of the real-life police interrogations of the two 10-year-old boys who killed a (male) toddler in England in 1993 is profoundly harrowing, and features deeply upsetting performances from its young stars. The mother of the murdered child has called for its nomination to be rescinded, and her pain is understandable, but this is an important examination of an inexplicable horror. And though it has been accused of somehow inappropriately “humanizing” the 10-year-old perpetrators, it only leaves us baffled as to how and why two children could commit such a heinous crime. [watch at Amazon US|Amazon UK|iTunes US|iTunes Can|iTunes UK]

The other nominees:

• “Fauve” [IMDb|official site], by Jeremy Comte, in which two young boys goofing around in a dangerous place are utterly unaware of the recklessness of their game of childish oneupmanship.

• “Mother” [IMDb], by Rodrigo Sorogoyen, a grim, bleak slice of terror in which a woman is tethered to her lost little boy by only a dying cell-phone connection.

• “Skin” [IMDb|official site], by Guy Nattiv, in which two young boys, one white and one black, witness a racist clash between their fathers; it’s a bit strained getting to its explosive ending, but its message of children learning what they are taught is well taken. Exciting up-and-comer Danielle Macdonald (Dumplin’) is featured as mother of one of the boys. [watch at Amazon US|Amazon UK|iTunes US|iTunes Can|iTunes UK]

• “Marguerite” [IMDb|official site], by Marianne Farley, the only film not about little boys, is a tender portrait of the relationship between an aging, ill woman and her visiting nurse, and the regret it inspires in the elder.


see also:
Oscar Nominated Animated Shorts 2019 (91st Academy Awards) review
Oscar Nominated Documentary Shorts 2019 (91st Academy Awards) review


Click here for my ranking of this and 2019’s other releases.



green light 3.5 stars

Oscar Nominated Live Action Shorts 2019 (91st Academy Awards) (2019) | directed by Vincent Lambe, Jeremy Comte, Marianne Farley, Rodrigo Sorogoyen, Guy Nattiv
US/Can release: Feb 08 2019
UK/Ire release: direct to VOD

MPAA: not rated
BBFC: not rated

viewed at home on PR-supplied physical media or screening link

official site | IMDb | trailer
more reviews: Movie Review Query Engine | Rotten Tomatoes

If you’re tempted to post a comment that resembles anything on the film review comment bingo card, please reconsider.

Pin It on Pinterest