Quantcast
please donate

since 1997 | by maryann johanson

Detroit movie review: racism 101 for white people

Detroit green light

MaryAnn’s quick take…
Tense, gripping, enraging, but only about things that black Americans already know. This is a primer about racism for white people, and we must pay attention.tweet
I’m “biast” (pro): nothing
I’m “biast” (con): nothing
(what is this about? see my critic’s minifesto)

Detroit is a movie about racism in America for white people. It mostly does not center black characters except as victims. Its villain — a murderously racist white cop — is also its protagonist. A movie about racism in America for white people isn’t the most terrible idea ever: Detroit wants to show us white people how the systematic weight of endless injustice weighs on black people, psychologically as well as physically, because of entrenched racism, not only of the actively vicious kind but also of the “I’m not getting involved, I’m just minding my own business” kind. (Black people don’t need to have this explained to them: they live it.) The film is very sympathetic to its black characters, though it engages the empathy of the audience mostly through physical violence done to them. Still: there are no white saviors here,tweet nor any kindly white people whose personal journeys are furthered by coming to a new appreciation of racism, and that’s a baby step of cinematic progress. A movie about racism in America for white people is maybe the best thing two white American storytellers — director Kathryn Bigelow, reteaming with her Zero Dark Thirty and Hurt Locker screenwriter Mark Boal — should attempt.

Your basic racist white cops.

Your basic racist white cops.tweet

But a movie like Detroit can only be a not-terrible thing as long as we start getting a lot more movies from black filmmakers telling their stories about racism from their perspectives. We cannot pretend that Detroit is the final cinematic word that can be said about the real-life event it depicts: the week-long riot, a near rebellion, in July 1967 in the Motor City that resulted in dozens of deaths, more than 1,000 injuries, and more than 7,000 arrests (although virtually no prosecutions). Detroit shouldn’t even be taken as the final cinematic word on the one narrow slice of horror it focuses on: the incident at the Algiers Motel on the night of July 25–6 in which 10 young black men (and two young white women) were psychologically and physically abused, and several killed, by white police officers. But it’s a start. Only a start.

It’s impossible not to be enraged by what we see here, and the film doesn’t even get into all the injustices at work.
tweet

The film is slow to get to what it is going to be about. The unrest began days before the Algiers Motel, when police raided an unlicensed social club and drinking establishment that catered to black people, and that’s where the film opens. Bigelow and Boal are, again, sympathetic to the people being raided: they’re not causing any trouble, just having a respectable good time; one is a soldier just back from Vietnam, Robert Greene (Anthony Mackie: Captain America: Civil War, Triple 9), a man who has put his life on the line for a nation that treats him like garbage. It’s impossible not to be enraged by this. But the film could have gone a step further and somehow let us know all the layers of injustice and harassment already at work here, such as, for instance, that a black person simply could not get a liquor license in Detroit in 1967, so it’s not like this is a matter of malicious criminality. It’s just people doing what they had to do to have the same sort of community white folks could have without any hassle.

The vacancies at the Algiers Motel: decency, humanity, kindness.

The vacancies at the Algiers Motel: decency, humanity, kindness.tweet

Anyway, the raid sparks some bottle- and rock-throwing at the police by the black onlookers, and everything explodes from there. Detroit gives a good impression of the city as a pile of tinder and every small act of oppression a spark: eventually, conflagration was inevitable. Really, someone could make a 20-hour miniseries about the Detroit riots — HBO, get on that — so perhaps it was a smart idea for Bigelow and Boal to wend their way toward the Algiers Motel a few nights later, where what happened was a microcosm for that tinder and that conflagration. In a city that feels like a war zone — damn near an apocalyptic one, with fires burning uncontrolled everywhere and armed soldiers patrolling, just total civic breakdown — the Algiers is an unexpected little oasis of normality, with a lot of friendly people, mostly black, just relaxing and hanging out and partying. Larry Reed (Algee Smith: Earth to Echo), a singer with a cool Motown group called The Dramatics, ends up here with his friend Fred Temple (Jacob Latimore: Collateral Beauty, The Maze Runner) as they try to find a safe haven amidst the violence; there they meet Juli Hysell (Hannah Murray: Game of Thrones, Dark Shadows) and Karen Malloy (Kaitlyn Dever: Men, Women & Children, Laggies), a couple of suburban white girls who like black boys, and some of their friends, including Carl Cooper (Jason Mitchell: Kong: Skull Island, Straight Outta Compton). Mackie’s Greene, the vet from the club raid, is here too.

Will Poulter is utterly horrifying as a murderously racist white cop, and also completely plausible and authentic.
tweet

Things go very bad when a prank with a starter pistol draws nearby cops and National Guardsmen, who are already on edge after days of rioting. Krauss*, a young city cop, takes it upon himself to lead an interrogation of everyone in the motel to find what he believes is a real gun, as well as who seemingly fired it at them. We have seen him behaving, in the earlier days of the riot, like a violent racist dirtbag, and he doubles down on this now. Will Poulter (The Revenant, Plastic) is utterly horrifying as Krauss revels in his power over others, particularly over people he considers inferior to his own proud self bloated by his authority; it gets very difficult to watch his Krauss torturing his prisoners, playing “games” in which he threatens to kill them if they don’t tell him what he wants to know. This should be difficult to watch, and if Krauss is so outrageously malevolent that he’s almost a caricature, Poulter’s performance is so rooted in straight-up bigoted rage that he remains completely plausible. His sidekicks — fellow cops Flynn (Ben O’Toole: The Water Diviner), sweaty and eager to hurt people, and Demens (Jack Reynor: Free Fire, A Royal Night Out), an earnest lackey who seems to want nothing else but to please Krauss — also keep him grounded in authenticity. These are very bad men who are all too real. (Not much better are the Guardsmen who refuse to get involved, who turn a blind eye even when they know that what is happening is an atrocity.)

It seems torture is easier if you don’t look your victims in the eye.

It seems torture is easier if you don’t look your victims in the eye.tweet

Perhaps the best, smartest aspect of Detroit is how it portrays the absolute impossibility of any black person successfully navigating the racist institutions and deep-rooted attitudes that pervade American society. Before everything goes to hell at the Algiers, Carl and a friend of his engage in a bit of playacting to demonstrate to the white women how a black man’s encounter with a police officer (the vast majority of whom were white in Detroit in 1967) would inevitably go: no amount of polite respect or deferring to authority would be enough. It’s even more insidious — and heartbreaking — in the character of Melvin Dismukes (John Boyega: Star Wars: The Force Awakens, Half of a Yellow Sun), a black security guard at a store nearby to the Algiers who had ingratiated himself with the white Guardsmen out of sheer self-protection: he doesn’t want to get shot because of the color of his skin. He follows them to the Algiers, and when he sees — and instantly understands — what is happening, he remains on the scene, ostensibly on the “side” of the cops and Guardsmen yet, we can see, clearly intending to try to diffuse the situation as much as he can with whatever bit of authority he can muster. His security-guard’s uniform isn’t much in the grand scheme, nor is his status as a “good negro,” but he does what he can. But taking up a position with the oppressor rarely works out well for the oppressed. (Boyega is excellent here. At one point I suddenly saw a physical resemblance, something in his eyes, that reminded me of Denzel Washington, which I’d never noticed in his previous screen outings, and then I realized it was because Boyega was bringing an even more robust potency his character than he has before, something akin to Washington’s gravitas. Boyega, already a really good actor, is going to be a truly great one someday soon.tweet)

The Detroit riots were 50 years ago — half a century! — and not much has changed for black Americans.
tweet

As a thriller, Detroit is tense and thoroughly gripping.tweet As a cultural exploration, it is completely infuriating. Everything we see here looks and sounds almost exactly like everything we’ve been seeing happening in America in recent years: the utter disdain for black bodies, black perspectives, and black lives. The Detroit riots were 50 years ago — half a century! — and really, nothing has changed in all that time? Of course, black people already knew this. It’s time — long past time — for white people to truly begin to understand this. Detroit is only a small piece of the beginning of such an understanding. But it’s a start. It’s a start.

*The names of the cops have been fictionalized and the cop characters are composites, because there is no irrefutable account of what happened at the Algiers — this is based on survivors’ stories, and no one has the complete tale — and also because the real cops were never convicted of any crime, thanks to — you guessed it — all-white juries. See The Hollywood Reporter for a detailed look at the legal niceties of this matter. All the other characters bear the names of the real people involved.


green light 4.5 stars

FlickFilosopher.com is wholly supported by readers. Please make a one-time donation (PayPal account NOT required) -- even $1 helps -- or set up a recurring subscription (PayPal account required).

Like what you’re reading? Sign up for the daily digest email and get links to all the day’s new reviews and other posts.

Detroit (2017) | directed by Kathryn Bigelow
US/Can release: Jul 28 2017
UK/Ire release: Aug 25 2017

MPAA: rated R for strong violence and pervasive language
BBFC: rated 15 (strong threat, violence, language)

viewed at a private screening with an audience of critics

official site | IMDb | trailer
more reviews: Movie Review Query Engine | Rotten Tomatoes

If you’re tempted to post a comment that resembles anything on the film review comment bingo card, you might want to reconsider.

  • goldrushapple

    >the utter disdain for black bodies, black perspectives, and black lives

    1. black on black crime in Chicago.
    2. last time I heard BLM weren’t protesting against #1

    >. It’s time — long past time — for white people to truly begin to understand this.

    Bah. Same old same old from your type. And I’m not even white,

    Facts don’t care about your feelings. The product of white people “understanding” has been embarrassing. Look at college campuses were “diversity and inclusion” have practically ruined the landscape. Have you heard of University of Missouri? Enrollment plummeted after the PC fiasco a couple of years ago where they had to close down two dorms because not enough students matriculated.

  • dee

    First, it should be noted — though already painfully obvious — that the USA still has a problem with overt racism, decades after the Civil Rights era. I’m Caucasian — “white” — by birth, so that’s up front, too. I grew up an Army brat, and for years all I knew were the integrated “neighborhoods” on military bases, before moving to a coincidentally integrated nieghborhood on the coast of Texas (right near Port Aransas). I had plenty of racism directed my way — from Latino boys, usually, looking to pick a fight; but also from the black boys (they weren’t men, hence boys is correct) who also picked on me (I was white AND small and skinny). But I saw plenty of racism directed toward chicanos and blacks, so I never formed a racist opinion or attitude.
    I’m certain I’m not THAT much of an anomaly. While there are plenty of whites who are racist, I don’t believe ALL whites are racist. Thus, the moronic slant of this article — especially the title — serves only to form yet another stereotype. And build yet another obstacle in the path of making the world LESS racist.
    If you wrote the article — you clearly wrote the article’s title with this intent — simply to draw attention and get lots of “clicks”, you’ve done yourself and black people a major disservice.
    By the way: I own a copy of “Get Out” — TERRIFIC, entertaining, and even thoughtful movie. Unlike this review.

  • Dale Snow

    Amazing that the first two comments are from non-racist people! What a coincidence, and what an advanced and enlightened bunch of people you have reading your site. That said, I still think the movie sounds like it would be of tremendous value to a lot of the white people I know. Thank you for the thoughtful and heartfelt review. We don’t know our history very well in this country, as you point out, and it would be of great use in negotiating our present.

  • amanohyo

    1. If you spend any amount of time with African Americans (or black people if you prefer non PC), you will quickly see that they often discuss and try to find solutions to the problem of violence in their communities. Typically these solutions are presented in a religious context, which I think hamstrings their attempts somewhat, but that’s another issue that affects people of all races.

    2. I won’t speak for BLM, but as far as I understand it, the movement began out of anger over several unarmed black men being shot by police officers with no repercussions. There is a difference between a young gang member killing an innocent bystander and a police officer killing an innocent bystander. In one case, a system put in place to uphold the law, protect the innocent (and the interests of the powerful for you cynics/realists), and serve the community appears to be above the law, acting unjustly, and actively hostile to the community.

    When it comes to the tangentially related issue of PC culture on college campuses, I’m right there with you dude. Legislating or censoring hate speech is a losing strategy, especially when the president regularly engages in what would be considered hate speech in many PC circles. Stupidity and anger are like mold. They don’t vanish when they’re gagged and kept in the dark. In a country with a decent educational system, bad ideas would wither and die when they’re brought into the light and placed beside better, more truthful ones. Sadly, this is not the case here. The logical focus should be on improving education not on increasing the censorship of ignorance.

  • Thank you for proving every damn point I made in my review.

  • Congrats! You went right to “Not all white people!” You win the comments section today.

    You also win for “I own a copy of GET OUT so I can’t be racist.” I think you’ve just invented the new “Some of my best friends are black people.”

    You might want to start looking into the difference between “somebody not white was mean to me, a white person” and racism. They aren’t the same thing.

  • IntrepidNormal

    I am not in a huge rush to see this one. As a black woman, I simply don’t need to watch another film about black suffering right now. But I am glad it exists, because there are many out there who probably do need to see it.

  • goldrushapple

    You know what MaryAnn, just because you say certain things doesn’t them true or even accurate. Try a cup of humbleness with a dash of true humility in the morning, and less of undeserved indignation. Thanks.

  • goldrushapple

    1. I’m aware of this. Throughout high school and college I’m been sensitive and knowledgeable of the efforts within black (logically if you have US citizenship you’re an American, not anything hyphenated … My passport doesn’t say “Asian-American” under nationality) communities. In fact I’m preparing to become a school social worker with hopes of working in the Chicago Public School system to focus with at-risk youths (who so happen to be black).

    To reiterate my focus group: I’m speaking of BLM.

    2. The case of George Zimmerman (death of Trayvon Martin) started the BLM movement. The media leads you believe that Martin was just some innocent kid just skipping home after buying Skittles.

    3. What counts as “hate speech”? What opposing views and ideologies count as “hate speech” that were brought unto campuses that resulted in meltdowns, public property damaged and actual physical assaults and threats towards those not protesting?

  • goldrushapple

    As you can tell from MaryAnn’s reply she isn’t much for sound reasoning and rationality.

    Lemme guess MaryAnn’s thoughts that went unwritten when she read your post. “Ugh. Another WHITE man who just doesn’t Get. It!” You see, when whites question condescending remarks from liberals (well, I’d categorize MaryAnn as a leftist), god forbid anyone shows a little grit in their remarks when questioning them, they just go berserk. But at the same time it’s a bit sad. The berkserk-ness that is. Oh well.

    “Ugh. White people. Ugh.” – the unwritten words of MaryAnn Johanson.

  • Dr. Rocketscience

    Did you know, the North Atlantic Ocean appears to be an ideal habitat for sea lions, but no species of sea lions live in the NAO, and no one knows why.

  • Ironic.

  • goldrushapple

    Great argument. Phi Beta Kappa stuff.

Pin It on Pinterest